Display Technologies, LLC v. Discord Inc.
5:24-cv-00703
Overview
Case Number
5:24-cv-00703
Filing Date
2024-02-06
Status
Litigation filed
Court
cand
Nature of Suit
830 Patent
Parties
Witness
TD BANK TD Bank
Represented By
1 Attorneys ListedDuane Morris LLP
Tel: +1 (415) 957-3000
Fax: +1 (415) 957-3001
One Market Plaza, Spear Tower, Suite 2200
Defendant
Discord Inc.
Represented By
3 Attorneys ListedFrancesca Miki Shima Germinario
Warren Kash Warren LLP
Tel: +1 (415) 895-2940
Fax: +1 (415) 895-2964
606, 2261 Market Street No. 606
Warren Kash Warren LLP
Tel: +1 (415) 895-2940
2261 Market Street No. 606, San Francisco, CA 94114
Warren Kash Warren LLP
Tel: +1 (415) 895-2940
Fax: +1 (415) 895-2964
2261 Market Street, No. 606, San Francisco, CA 94114
Plaintiff
Display Technologies, LLC
Represented By
1 Attorneys ListedGARTEISER HONEA IP TRIAL BOUTIQUE
Tel: +1 (888) 908-4400
GARTEISER HONEA IP TRIAL BOUTIQUE, 795 Folsom St., Floor 1
Court & Judges
Court
cand
Patents Involved
No asserted patent numbers detected in initial docket filings yet.
Docket Entries
COMPLAINT against Discord Inc. ( Filing fee $ 405, receipt number ACANDC-19098406.). Filed by Display Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - Patent, # 2 Exhibit 2 - Claim Chart, # 3 Exhibit 3 - Patent, # 4 Exhibit 4 - Claim Chart, # 5 Civil Cover Sheet)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
1
COMPLAINT against Discord Inc. ( Filing fee $ 405, receipt number ACANDC-19098406.). Filed by Display Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - Patent, # 2 Exhibit 2 - Claim Chart, # 3 Exhibit 3 - Patent, # 4 Exhibit 4 - Claim Chart, # 5 Civil Cover Sheet)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
2
COMPLAINT against Discord Inc. ( Filing fee $ 405, receipt number ACANDC-19098406.). Filed by Display Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - Patent, # 2 Exhibit 2 - Claim Chart, # 3 Exhibit 3 - Patent, # 4 Exhibit 4 - Claim Chart, # 5 Civil Cover Sheet)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
2
COMPLAINT against Discord Inc. ( Filing fee $ 405, receipt number ACANDC-19098406.). Filed by Display Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - Patent, # 2 Exhibit 2 - Claim Chart, # 3 Exhibit 3 - Patent, # 4 Exhibit 4 - Claim Chart, # 5 Civil Cover Sheet)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
2
COMPLAINT against Discord Inc. ( Filing fee $ 405, receipt number ACANDC-19098406.). Filed by Display Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - Patent, # 2 Exhibit 2 - Claim Chart, # 3 Exhibit 3 - Patent, # 4 Exhibit 4 - Claim Chart, # 5 Civil Cover Sheet)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
2
COMPLAINT against Discord Inc. ( Filing fee $ 405, receipt number ACANDC-19098406.). Filed by Display Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - Patent, # 2 Exhibit 2 - Claim Chart, # 3 Exhibit 3 - Patent, # 4 Exhibit 4 - Claim Chart, # 5 Civil Cover Sheet)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
2
REPORT on the filing or determination of an action regarding (cc: form mailed to register). (Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
1
Proposed Summons. (Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
1
Case assigned to Magistrate Judge Nathanael M. Cousins. Counsel for plaintiff or the removing party is responsible for serving the Complaint or Notice of Removal, Summons and the assigned judge's standing orders and all other new case documents upon the opposing parties. For information, visit E-Filing A New Civil Case at http://cand.uscourts.gov/ecf/caseopening.Standing orders can be downloaded from the court's web page at www.cand.uscourts.gov/judges. Upon receipt, the summons will be issued and returned electronically. A scheduling order will be sent by Notice of Electronic Filing (NEF) within two business days. Consent/Declination due by 2/20/2024. (cv, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/06/2024)
2024-02-06
1
Initial Case Management Scheduling Order with ADR Deadlines: Case Management Statement due by 5/1/2024. Initial Case Management Conference set for 5/8/2024 10:00 AM in San Jose, Courtroom 5, 4th Floor. (dhm, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 2/6/2024) (Entered: 02/08/2024)
2024-02-06
1
~Util - Case Assigned by Intake
2024-02-06
1
No Actions
Summons Issued as to Discord Inc.. (dhm, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 2/8/2024) (Entered: 02/08/2024)
2024-02-08
1
CLERK'S NOTICE RE: Consent or Declination. Plaintiff is requested to file a consent or declination to proceed before a magistrate judge. Note that any party is free to withhold consent to proceed before a magistrate judge without adverse substantive consequences. The forms are available at: http://cand.uscourts.gov/civilforms. Consent/Declination due by 3/12/2024. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (lmh, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 2/27/2024) (Entered: 02/27/2024)
2024-02-27
1
Clerk's Notice re: Consent or Declination
2024-02-27
1
No Actions
NOTICE of Appearance by Matthew S. Warren (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 2/29/2024) (Entered: 02/29/2024)
2024-02-29
1
NOTICE of Appearance by Erika H. Warren (Warren, Erika) (Filed on 2/29/2024) (Entered: 02/29/2024)
2024-02-29
1
NOTICE of Appearance by Francesca Miki Shima Germinario (Germinario, Francesca Miki Shima) (Filed on 2/29/2024) (Entered: 02/29/2024)
2024-02-29
1
STIPULATION re 1 Complaint, Extending Time to Respond to March 29, 2024 filed by Discord Inc.. (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 2/29/2024) (Entered: 02/29/2024)
2024-02-29
1
Rule 7.1 Disclosures by Discord Inc. (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/4/2024) (Entered: 03/04/2024)
2024-03-04
1
Certificate of Interested Entities by Discord Inc. Under Civil Local Rule 3-15 (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/4/2024) (Entered: 03/04/2024)
2024-03-04
1
CONSENT/DECLINATION to Proceed Before a US Magistrate Judge by Discord Inc... (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/12/2024) (Entered: 03/12/2024)
2024-03-12
1
CLERK'S NOTICE OF IMPENDING REASSIGNMENT TO A U.S. DISTRICT COURT JUDGE: The Clerk of this Court will now randomly reassign this case to a District Judge because a party has not consented to the jurisdiction of a Magistrate Judge. You will be informed by separate notice of the district judge to whom this case is reassigned. ALL HEARING DATES PRESENTLY SCHEDULED BEFORE THE CURRENT MAGISTRATE JUDGE ARE VACATED AND WILL BE RE-NOTICED FOR HEARING BEFORE THE JUDGE TO WHOM THIS CASE IS REASSIGNED. This is a text only docket entry; there is no document associated with this notice. (lmh, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 3/13/2024) (Entered: 03/13/2024)
2024-03-13
1
ORDER REASSIGNING CASE. Case reassigned using a proportionate, random, and blind system pursuant to General Order No. 44 to Judge P. Casey Pitts for all further proceedings. Magistrate Judge Nathanael M. Cousins no longer assigned to case, except for discovery purposes. Notice: The assigned judge participates in the Cameras in the Courtroom Pilot Project. See General Order No. 65 and http://cand.uscourts.gov/cameras. (Attachments: # 1 Notice of Eligibility for Video Recording)(sfb, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 3/13/2024) (Entered: 03/13/2024)
2024-03-13
1
ORDER REASSIGNING CASE. Case reassigned using a proportionate, random, and blind system pursuant to General Order No. 44 to Judge P. Casey Pitts for all further proceedings. Magistrate Judge Nathanael M. Cousins no longer assigned to case, except for discovery purposes. Notice: The assigned judge participates in the Cameras in the Courtroom Pilot Project. See General Order No. 65 and http://cand.uscourts.gov/cameras. (Attachments: # 1 Notice of Eligibility for Video Recording)(sfb, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 3/13/2024) (Entered: 03/13/2024)
2024-03-13
2
Clerk's Notice of Impending Reassignment - Text Only
2024-03-13
1
No Actions
CLERK'S NOTICE RESETTING CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE FOLLOWING REASSIGNMENT. Joint Case Management Statement due by 5/2/2024. Initial Case Management Conference set for 5/16/2024 at 01:00 PM in San Jose, Courtroom 8, 4th Floor. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (nmc, COURT USER) (Filed on 3/14/2024) (Entered: 03/14/2024)
2024-03-14
1
Clerk's Notice AND ~Util - Set Motion and Deadlines/Hearings
2024-03-14
1
No Actions
ANSWER to Complaint with Jury Demand by Discord Inc.. (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
1
MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed by Discord Inc.. Motion to Dismiss Hearing set for 5/16/2024 10:00 AM. Responses due by 4/12/2024. Replies due by 4/19/2024. (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
1
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
1
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Patent Asset Management, LLC Annual Report, # 2 Ex. 2: Display Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 3 Ex. 3: Display Technologies, LLC Certificate of Formation, # 4 Ex. 4: Declaration of Jay Johnson in Display Technologies, LLC v. Mocacare Corp., No. 22-219 (N.D. Cal.), # 5 Ex. 5: Affidavit of Jay Johnson in Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC v. WizIQ, Inc., No. 21-10694 (D. Mass.), # 6 Ex. 6: Declaration of Leigh Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A. LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 7 Ex. 7: Matthew Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 8 Ex. 8: Ariel Inventions, LLC Annual Report, # 9 Ex. 9: Reagan Inventions, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 10 Ex. 10: Rothschild Broadcast Distribution Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 11 Ex. 11: Symbology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 12 Ex. 12: Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 13 Ex. 13: Location Based Services, LLC Public Information Report, # 14 Ex. 14: Rothschild Patent Imaging LLC Public Information Report, # 15 Ex. 15: Digital Verification Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 16 Ex. 16: Coding Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 17 Ex. 17: Electronic Receipts Delivery Systems LLC Public Information Report, # 18 Ex. 18: Product Association Technologies, LLC Public Information Report, # 19 Ex. 19: Rothschild Digital Confirmation, LLC Public Information Report, # 20 Ex. 20: Geographic Location Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 21 Ex. 21: RFID Technology Innovations, LLC Public Information Report, # 22 Ex. 22: Rothschild Biometrics Systems, LLC Public Information Report, # 23 Ex. 23: Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 24 Ex. 24: Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC Annual Report, # 25 Ex. 25: Rothschild Trust Holdings, L.L.C. Annual Report, # 26 Ex. 26: Rothschild Location Technologies LLC Public Information Report, # 27 Ex. 27: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Mobile Imaging Innovations, LLC v. Bank of America Corp., No. 14-1142 (D. Del.), # 28 Ex. 28: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 29 Ex. 29: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Smartosc, US LLC, No. 19-1002 (W.D. Wash.), # 30 Ex. 30: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Scanning Technologies Innovations LLC v. Pegasus U.S.A., LLC, No. 22-1157 (D.N.J.), # 31 Ex. 31: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Display Technologies, LLC v. Aston Martin, LLC, No. 20-258 (D. Del.), # 32 Ex. 32: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC v. H&M System Software, Inc., No. 22-1161 (D.N.J.), # 33 Ex. 33: Affidavit of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Taigle, LLC, No. 21-809 (C.D. Cal.), # 34 Ex. 34: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Connected Devices Innovations, LLC v. Guardian Protection Services, Inc., No. 15-1431 (E.D. Tex.), # 35 Ex. 35: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothchild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 36 Ex. 36: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Digital Media Innovations, LLC v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. 14-3928 (N.D. Cal.), # 37 Ex. 37: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 14-22653 (N.D. Cal.), # 38 Ex. 38: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 39 Ex. 39: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. LG Electronics Inc., No. 15-2500 (N.D. Cal.), # 40 Ex. 40: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. HTC Corp., No. 15-373 (N.D. Cal.), # 41 Ex. 41: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 42 Ex. 42: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co., No. 15-539 (N.D. Cal.), # 43 Ex. 43: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Apple Inc., No. 15-541 (N.D. Cal.), # 44 Ex. 44: Complaint in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-1641 (D. Conn.), # 45 Ex. 45: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 46 Ex. 46: Deposition Transcript of Leigh M. Rothschild in Digital Verification Systems, LLC v. Encyro, Inc., No. 22-686 (C.D. Cal.), # 47 Ex. 47: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Rothschild Storage Retrieval Innovations, LLC v. Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., No. 15-234 (N.D. Cal.), # 48 Ex. 48: Declaration of Leigh M. Rothschild in Symbology Innovations, LLC v. Lego Systems, Inc., No. 17-86 (E.D. Va.), # 49 Ex. 49: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Discord Inc. dated February 15, 2023, # 50 Ex. 50: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated April 12, 2023, # 51 Ex. 51: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated May 30, 2023, # 52 Ex. 52: Letter from Matthew Hawkinson to Renita Rathinam dated June 20, 2023, # 53 Ex. 53: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated July 7, 2023, # 54 Ex. 54: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Hawkinson dated October 5, 2023, # 55 Ex. 55: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 3, 2023, # 56 Ex. 56: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated November 17, 2023, # 57 Ex. 57: Letter from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated November 28, 2023, # 58 Ex. 58: Letter from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated December 15, 2023, # 59 Ex. 59: Email from Renita Rathinam to Matthew Warren dated January 5, 2024, # 60 Ex. 60: Email from Matthew Warren to Renita Rathinam dated January 11, 2024, # 61 Ex. 61: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 62 Ex. 62: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 24, 2024, # 63 Ex. 63: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 25, 2024, # 64 Ex. 64: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated March 12, 2024, # 65 Ex. 65: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 26, 2024, # 66 Ex. 66: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated January 29, 2024, # 67 Ex. 67: Email from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated January 31, 2024, # 68 Ex. 68: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated February 8, 2024, # 69 Ex. 69: Global Settlement and License Agreement in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 70 Ex. 70: Second Amended Complaint in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 71 Ex. 71: Defendants Motion to Dismiss in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 72 Ex. 72: Agreement Between Rothschild Patent Imaging, LLC, Leigh Rothschild, and the GNOME Foundation, dated May 20, 2020, # 73 Ex. 73: Lessons from the GNOME Patent Troll Incident, blog post dated September 3, 2020)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
2
Request for Judicial Notice re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 3/29/2024) (Entered: 03/29/2024)
2024-03-29
1
Rule 7.1 Disclosures by Display Technologies, LLC identifying Corporate Parent Patent Asset Management, LLC for Display Technologies, LLC. (Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 4/5/2024) (Entered: 04/05/2024)
2024-04-05
1
Certificate of Interested Entities by Display Technologies, LLC identifying Corporate Parent Patent Asset Management, LLC for Display Technologies, LLC. (Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 4/5/2024) (Entered: 04/05/2024)
2024-04-05
1
OPPOSITION/RESPONSE (re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing ), 20 EXHIBITS, and 21 REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE, filed byDisplay Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 4/12/2024) (Entered: 04/12/2024)
2024-04-12
1
OPPOSITION/RESPONSE (re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing ), 20 EXHIBITS, and 21 REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE, filed byDisplay Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 4/12/2024) (Entered: 04/12/2024)
2024-04-12
2
REPLY (re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing ) filed byDiscord Inc.. (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 4/19/2024) (Entered: 04/19/2024)
2024-04-19
1
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 25 Reply to Opposition/Response re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 74: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 1, 2024, # 2 Ex. 75: Letter from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated April 3, 2024, # 3 Ex. 76: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 10, 2024, # 4 Ex. 77: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 11, 2024)(Related document(s) 25 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 4/19/2024) (Entered: 04/19/2024)
2024-04-19
1
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 25 Reply to Opposition/Response re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 74: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 1, 2024, # 2 Ex. 75: Letter from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated April 3, 2024, # 3 Ex. 76: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 10, 2024, # 4 Ex. 77: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 11, 2024)(Related document(s) 25 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 4/19/2024) (Entered: 04/19/2024)
2024-04-19
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 25 Reply to Opposition/Response re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 74: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 1, 2024, # 2 Ex. 75: Letter from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated April 3, 2024, # 3 Ex. 76: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 10, 2024, # 4 Ex. 77: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 11, 2024)(Related document(s) 25 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 4/19/2024) (Entered: 04/19/2024)
2024-04-19
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 25 Reply to Opposition/Response re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 74: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 1, 2024, # 2 Ex. 75: Letter from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated April 3, 2024, # 3 Ex. 76: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 10, 2024, # 4 Ex. 77: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 11, 2024)(Related document(s) 25 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 4/19/2024) (Entered: 04/19/2024)
2024-04-19
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 25 Reply to Opposition/Response re 19 MOTION to Dismiss For Lack of Standing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 74: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 1, 2024, # 2 Ex. 75: Letter from Matthew Warren to Randall Garteiser dated April 3, 2024, # 3 Ex. 76: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 10, 2024, # 4 Ex. 77: Email from Randall Garteiser to Matthew Warren dated April 11, 2024)(Related document(s) 25 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 4/19/2024) (Entered: 04/19/2024)
2024-04-19
2
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER to Reset the Initial Case Management Conference and Related Deadlines filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 4/25/2024) (Entered: 04/25/2024)
2024-04-25
1
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER to Reset the Initial Case Management Conference and Related Deadlines filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 4/25/2024) (Entered: 04/25/2024)
2024-04-25
2
ORDER granting *as modified* 27 Stipulation to Reset the Initial Case Management Conference and Related Deadlines. Signed by Judge P. Casey Pitts on 4/29/2024. Joint Case Management Statement due by 5/30/2024. Initial Case Management Conference set for 6/13/2024 at 01:00 PM in San Jose, Courtroom 8, 4th Floor. (nmc, COURT USER) (Filed on 4/29/2024) (Entered: 04/29/2024)
2024-04-29
1
STATEMENT OF RECENT DECISION pursuant to Civil Local Rule 7-3.d filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. A: Intellectual Tech LLC v. Zebra Technologies Corporation)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/1/2024) (Entered: 05/01/2024)
2024-05-01
1
STATEMENT OF RECENT DECISION pursuant to Civil Local Rule 7-3.d filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. A: Intellectual Tech LLC v. Zebra Technologies Corporation)(Related document(s) 19 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/1/2024) (Entered: 05/01/2024)
2024-05-01
2
Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge P. Casey Pitts: Motion Hearing re 19 Motion to Dismiss For Lack of Standing held on 5/16/2024. Argument of counsel heard. Plaintiff shall file any further evidence in support of their opposition by 5/23/2024. Defendant may file a response by 5/30/2024. Once filed, the motion will be taken under submission without further oral argument.Total Time in Court: 16 min (10:51-11:07 AM). Court Reporter: Lee-Anne Shortridge. Plaintiff Attorney: Randall Garteiser (via Zoom). Defendant Attorney: Matthew Warren. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (nmc, COURT USER) (Date Filed: 5/16/2024). (Entered: 05/16/2024)
2024-05-16
1
TRANSCRIPT ORDER for proceedings held on 05/16/2024 before Judge P. Casey Pitts by Discord Inc., for Court Reporter Lee-Anne Shortridge. (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/16/2024) (Entered: 05/16/2024)
2024-05-16
1
1 - Terminate Hearings AND Motion Hearing
2024-05-16
1
No Actions
ADR Certification (ADR L.R. 3-5 b) of discussion of ADR options (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/23/2024) (Entered: 05/23/2024)
2024-05-23
1
Supplemental Brief re 30 Motion Hearing,,, Terminate Hearings,, [Standing exists for Plaintiff] filed byDisplay Technologies, LLC. (Related document(s) 30 ) (Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 5/23/2024) (Entered: 05/23/2024)
2024-05-23
1
Transcript of Proceedings held on 5-16-24, before Judge P. Casey Pitts. Court Reporter Lee-Anne Shortridge, email: lee-anne_shortridge@cand.uscourts.gov. Per General Order No. 59 and Judicial Conference policy, this transcript may be viewed only at the Clerk's Office public terminal or may be purchased through the Court Reporter until the deadline for the Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained through PACER. Any Notice of Intent to Request Redaction, if required, is due no later than 5 business days from date of this filing. (Re 31 Transcript Order ) Release of Transcript Restriction set for 8/26/2024. (Related documents(s) 31 ) (las, ) (Filed on 5/28/2024) (Entered: 05/28/2024)
2024-05-28
1
JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT filed by Discord Inc.. (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/30/2024) (Entered: 05/30/2024)
2024-05-30
1
Supplemental Brief re 33 Supplemental Brief Response to Supplemental Filing filed byDiscord Inc.. (Related document(s) 33 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/30/2024) (Entered: 05/30/2024)
2024-05-30
1
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 36 Supplemental Brief filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 78: Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 2 Ex. 79: Email from Daniel Falcucci to Valve Corporation dated March 15, 2022 attached to Docket No. 38 in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 3 Ex. 80: Defendants Reply in Support of Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.))(Related document(s) 36 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/30/2024) (Entered: 05/30/2024)
2024-05-30
1
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 36 Supplemental Brief filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 78: Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 2 Ex. 79: Email from Daniel Falcucci to Valve Corporation dated March 15, 2022 attached to Docket No. 38 in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 3 Ex. 80: Defendants Reply in Support of Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.))(Related document(s) 36 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/30/2024) (Entered: 05/30/2024)
2024-05-30
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 36 Supplemental Brief filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 78: Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 2 Ex. 79: Email from Daniel Falcucci to Valve Corporation dated March 15, 2022 attached to Docket No. 38 in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 3 Ex. 80: Defendants Reply in Support of Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.))(Related document(s) 36 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/30/2024) (Entered: 05/30/2024)
2024-05-30
2
Declaration of Francesca Miki Shima Germinario in Support of 36 Supplemental Brief filed byDiscord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 78: Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 2 Ex. 79: Email from Daniel Falcucci to Valve Corporation dated March 15, 2022 attached to Docket No. 38 in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.), # 3 Ex. 80: Defendants Reply in Support of Defendants Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs Second Amended Complaint for Declaratory Judgment in Valve Corporation v. Rothschild, No. 23-1016 (W.D. Wash.))(Related document(s) 36 ) (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/30/2024) (Entered: 05/30/2024)
2024-05-30
2
ADR Certification (ADR L.R. 3-5 b) of discussion of ADR options by Plaintiff Display Technologies, LLC (Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 6/3/2024) (Entered: 06/03/2024)
2024-06-03
1
MOTION FOR LEAVE FOR RANDALL GARTEISER TO APPEAR REMOTELY at the Initial Case Management Conference set for 6/13/2024 at 01:00 PM in San Jose, Courtroom 8, 4th Floor. re 28 Order on Stipulation, filed by Display Technologies, LLC. Responses due by 6/21/2024. Replies due by 6/28/2024. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 6/7/2024) (Entered: 06/07/2024)
2024-06-07
1
MOTION FOR LEAVE FOR RANDALL GARTEISER TO APPEAR REMOTELY at the Initial Case Management Conference set for 6/13/2024 at 01:00 PM in San Jose, Courtroom 8, 4th Floor. re 28 Order on Stipulation, filed by Display Technologies, LLC. Responses due by 6/21/2024. Replies due by 6/28/2024. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 6/7/2024) (Entered: 06/07/2024)
2024-06-07
2
ORDER granting 39 Motion for Randall Garteiser to Appear Remotely. Initial Case Management Conference set for 6/13/2024 previously set at 01:00 PM is RESET FOR 02:00 PM in San Jose, Courtroom 8, 4th Floor. Signed by Judge P. Casey Pitts on 6/11/2024.(nmc, COURT USER) (Filed on 6/11/2024) (Entered: 06/11/2024)
2024-06-11
1
CLERK'S NOTICE RESETTING TIME OF INITIAL CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE. Initial Case Management Conference set for 6/13/2024 is RESET for 01:00 PM in San Jose, Courtroom 8, 4th Floor. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (nmc, COURT USER) (Filed on 6/12/2024) (Entered: 06/12/2024)
2024-06-12
1
1 - Terminate Hearings AND Clerk's Notice AND ~Util - Set Motion and Deadlines/Hearings
2024-06-12
1
No Actions
Minute Entry for proceedings held before Judge P. Casey Pitts: Initial Case Management Conference held on 6/13/2024. The Court orders jurisdictional discovery on the issue of whether plaintiff Display has standing to bring this lawsuit. Responses to discovery requests must be produced within 21 days and any discovery disputes may be submitted within 14 days thereafter, but the Court expects the parties to work together towards the resolution of such disputes. Any discovery disputes that do come before the Court will be resolved pursuant to the procedures in Judge Pitts's Standing Order.Defendant Discord must file a 15-page supplemental brief by September 13, 2024 based on the evidence obtained from jurisdictional discovery. Display must respond with its 15-page opposition brief by September 27, 2024. If it so chooses, Discord may file a 5-page reply brief by October 4, 2024. All other discovery will be stayed pending jurisdictional discovery and the Court will not issue a case schedule at this time. The Court also sets a status conference for August 8, 2024 at 01:00 PM.Total Time in Court: 31 min (1:00-1:31 PM). Court Reporter: Lee-Anne Shortridge. Plaintiff Attorney: Randall Garteiser (via Zoom). Defendant Attorney: Matthew Warren. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (nmc, COURT USER) (Date Filed: 6/14/2024) (Entered: 06/14/2024)
2024-06-14
1
TRANSCRIPT ORDER for proceedings held on June 13, 2024 before Judge P. Casey Pitts by Discord Inc., for Court Reporter Lee-Anne Shortridge. (Germinario, Francesca Miki Shima) (Filed on 6/14/2024) (Entered: 06/14/2024)
2024-06-14
1
1 - Terminate Hearings AND Case Management Conference - Initial AND ~Util - Set Deadlines/Hearings
2024-06-14
1
No Actions
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER Requesting Entry of Protective Order filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Redline of Stipulated Proposed Protective Order Against the District Model Protective Order, # 2 Stipulated Proposed Protective Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 6/26/2024) (Entered: 06/26/2024)
2024-06-26
1
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER Requesting Entry of Protective Order filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Redline of Stipulated Proposed Protective Order Against the District Model Protective Order, # 2 Stipulated Proposed Protective Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 6/26/2024) (Entered: 06/26/2024)
2024-06-26
2
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER Requesting Entry of Protective Order filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: Redline of Stipulated Proposed Protective Order Against the District Model Protective Order, # 2 Stipulated Proposed Protective Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 6/26/2024) (Entered: 06/26/2024)
2024-06-26
2
STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER; Granting 44 . Signed by Judge Nathanael M. Cousins on 6/27/2024. (lmh, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 6/27/2024) (Entered: 06/27/2024)
2024-06-27
1
Transcript of Proceedings held on 6-13-24, before Judge P. Casey Pitts. Court Reporte Lee-Anne Shortridge, email: lee-anne_shortridge@cand.uscourts.gov. Per General Order No. 59 and Judicial Conference policy, this transcript may be viewed only at the Clerk's Office public terminal or may be purchased through the Court Reporter until the deadline for the Release of Transcript Restriction. After that date it may be obtained through PACER. Any Notice of Intent to Request Redaction, if required, is due no later than 5 business days from date of this filing. (Re 43 Transcript Order ) Release of Transcript Restriction set for 10/9/2024. (Related documents(s) 43 ) (las, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 7/11/2024) (Entered: 07/11/2024)
2024-07-11
1
NOTICE by Display Technologies, LLC of service of its Corrected OBJECTIONS DISCORDS THIRD-PARTY SUBPOENA TO TD BANK REGARDING NON-PARTY PATENT ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLCS PROTECTED INFORMATION (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - DISCORDS THIRD-PARTY SUBPOENA TO TD BANK REGARDING NON-PARTY PATENT ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLCS PROTECTED INFORMATION)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 7/15/2024) (Entered: 07/15/2024)
2024-07-15
1
NOTICE by Display Technologies, LLC of service of its Corrected OBJECTIONS DISCORDS THIRD-PARTY SUBPOENA TO TD BANK REGARDING NON-PARTY PATENT ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLCS PROTECTED INFORMATION (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - DISCORDS THIRD-PARTY SUBPOENA TO TD BANK REGARDING NON-PARTY PATENT ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLCS PROTECTED INFORMATION)(Garteiser, Randall) (Filed on 7/15/2024) (Entered: 07/15/2024)
2024-07-15
2
NOTICE by TD Bank / NON-PARTY TD BANKS OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS, INFORMATION, OR OBJECTS OR TO PERMIT INSPECTION OF PREMISES IN A CIVIL ACTION (Norris, Christopher) (Filed on 7/16/2024) (Entered: 07/16/2024)
2024-07-16
1
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER Requesting Extension of Deadlines filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/22/2024) (Entered: 07/22/2024)
2024-07-22
1
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER Requesting Extension of Deadlines filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/22/2024) (Entered: 07/22/2024)
2024-07-22
2
ORDER granting 49 Stipulation to Request Extension of Deadlines. Signed by Judge P. Casey Pitts on 7/23/2024. (nmc, COURT USER) (Filed on 7/23/2024) (Entered: 07/23/2024)
2024-07-23
1
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER Requesting Extension of Deadlines filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/29/2024) (Entered: 07/29/2024)
2024-07-29
1
STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED ORDER Requesting Extension of Deadlines filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/29/2024) (Entered: 07/29/2024)
2024-07-29
2
ORDER granting 51 Stipulation to Request Extension of Deadlines. Signed by Judge P. Casey Pitts on 7/30/2024. (nmc, COURT USER) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
1
Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Matthew S. Warren in support of Administrative Motion to File Under Seal by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Unredacted Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery, # 3 Unredacted Ex. 4 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 4 Unredacted Ex. 5 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 5 Unredacted Ex. 6 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 6 Discord Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
1
Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Matthew S. Warren in support of Administrative Motion to File Under Seal by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Unredacted Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery, # 3 Unredacted Ex. 4 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 4 Unredacted Ex. 5 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 5 Unredacted Ex. 6 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 6 Discord Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Matthew S. Warren in support of Administrative Motion to File Under Seal by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Unredacted Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery, # 3 Unredacted Ex. 4 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 4 Unredacted Ex. 5 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 5 Unredacted Ex. 6 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 6 Discord Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Matthew S. Warren in support of Administrative Motion to File Under Seal by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Unredacted Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery, # 3 Unredacted Ex. 4 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 4 Unredacted Ex. 5 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 5 Unredacted Ex. 6 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 6 Discord Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Matthew S. Warren in support of Administrative Motion to File Under Seal by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Unredacted Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery, # 3 Unredacted Ex. 4 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 4 Unredacted Ex. 5 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 5 Unredacted Ex. 6 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 6 Discord Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Matthew S. Warren in support of Administrative Motion to File Under Seal by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Unredacted Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery, # 3 Unredacted Ex. 4 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 4 Unredacted Ex. 5 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 5 Unredacted Ex. 6 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 6 Discord Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Matthew S. Warren in support of Administrative Motion to File Under Seal by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Unredacted Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery, # 3 Unredacted Ex. 4 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 4 Unredacted Ex. 5 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 5 Unredacted Ex. 6 to Joint Letter Brief: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 6 Discord Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Ex. 2: First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories by Defendant Discord Inc., # 3 Ex. 3: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission by Defendant Discord Inc., # 4 Redacted Ex. 4: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 5 Redacted Ex. 5: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 6 Redacted Ex. 6: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 7 Defendant Discord Inc. Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
1
Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Ex. 2: First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories by Defendant Discord Inc., # 3 Ex. 3: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission by Defendant Discord Inc., # 4 Redacted Ex. 4: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 5 Redacted Ex. 5: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 6 Redacted Ex. 6: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 7 Defendant Discord Inc. Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Ex. 2: First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories by Defendant Discord Inc., # 3 Ex. 3: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission by Defendant Discord Inc., # 4 Redacted Ex. 4: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 5 Redacted Ex. 5: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 6 Redacted Ex. 6: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 7 Defendant Discord Inc. Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Ex. 2: First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories by Defendant Discord Inc., # 3 Ex. 3: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission by Defendant Discord Inc., # 4 Redacted Ex. 4: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 5 Redacted Ex. 5: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 6 Redacted Ex. 6: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 7 Defendant Discord Inc. Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Ex. 2: First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories by Defendant Discord Inc., # 3 Ex. 3: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission by Defendant Discord Inc., # 4 Redacted Ex. 4: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 5 Redacted Ex. 5: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 6 Redacted Ex. 6: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 7 Defendant Discord Inc. Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Ex. 2: First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories by Defendant Discord Inc., # 3 Ex. 3: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission by Defendant Discord Inc., # 4 Redacted Ex. 4: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 5 Redacted Ex. 5: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 6 Redacted Ex. 6: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 7 Defendant Discord Inc. Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Ex. 2: First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories by Defendant Discord Inc., # 3 Ex. 3: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission by Defendant Discord Inc., # 4 Redacted Ex. 4: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 5 Redacted Ex. 5: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 6 Redacted Ex. 6: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 7 Defendant Discord Inc. Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
Joint Discovery Letter Brief regarding Jurisdictional Discovery filed by Discord Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production by Defendant Discord Inc., # 2 Ex. 2: First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories by Defendant Discord Inc., # 3 Ex. 3: First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission by Defendant Discord Inc., # 4 Redacted Ex. 4: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Production, # 5 Redacted Ex. 5: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Interrogatories, # 6 Redacted Ex. 6: Plaintiffs Responses to Defendants First Set of Jurisdictional Requests for Admission, # 7 Defendant Discord Inc. Proposed Order)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
2
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE by Discord Inc. re 53 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal (Germinario, Francesca Miki Shima) (Filed on 7/30/2024) (Entered: 07/30/2024)
2024-07-30
1
STIPULATION of Dismissal with Prejudice filed by Discord Inc.. (Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 7/31/2024) (Entered: 07/31/2024)
2024-07-31
1
TEXT-ONLY ORDER The parties have submitted a 55 joint discovery letter brief. As discussed at the Initial Case Management Conference, any disputes regarding jurisdictional discovery will be resolved by the assigned district judge. The Court will hear argument on the parties' dispute at the August 8, 2024 status conference. (This is a text-only entry generated by the court. There is no document associated with this entry.) (nmc, COURT USER) (Filed on 7/31/2024) (Entered: 07/31/2024)
2024-07-31
1
Order
2024-07-31
1
No Actions