CasLoc logo
All Cases PTAB Litigations UPC Oppositions

Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC v. ZTE (USA), Inc.

2:13-cv-00946

📡 5G SEP • ETSI Declared

Overview

Case Number 2:13-cv-00946
Filing Date 2013-11-07
Status Terminated
Termination Date 2016-12-06
Court District Court, E.D. Texas (txed)
Nature of Suit 830 Patent
Jurisdiction Type Federal Question
Cause of Action 35:271 Patent Infringement
Jury Demand Both

Parties

Mediator

David Folsom NPE (Individual / Inventor)

Represented By

1 Attorneys Listed

David Folsom

Jackson Walker, LLP

6002-B Summerfield Drive, Texarkana, TX 75503

Defendant

ZTE (USA), Inc. Operating Company

Represented By

8 Attorneys Listed

Wei Wei

Shore Chan DePumpo

Tel: +1 (214) 593-9110
Fax: +1 (214) 593-9111

Shore Chan DePumpo, 901 Main Street

Jennifer Marie Rynell

Wilson Legal Group, PC

Tel: +1 (972) 248-8080
Fax: +1 (972) 248-8088

16610 Dallas Parkway, Suite 1000

Everett McClyde Upshaw

Upshaw PLLC - Dallas

Tel: +1 (972) 920-8000
Fax: +1 (972) 920-8001

1204 Gano Street, Dallas, TX 75215

David A Bailey

Upshaw PLLC - Dallas

Tel: +1 (972) 920-8000
Fax: +1 (972) 920-8001

1204 Gano Street, Dallas, TX 75215

Craig Lee Uhrich

Craig Uhrich - Attorney at Law

Tel: +1 (785) 671-1237

311 Center Ave, Ste A

Christopher Charles Carnaval

Canon U.S.A., Inc

Tel: +1 (631) 330-5152

1 Canon Park, Melville, NY 11747

Alexas D Skucas

King & Spalding, LLP - New York

Tel: +1 (212) 827-4049
Fax: +1 (212) 556-2222

1185 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10036-4003

Alfonso Garcia Chan

Shore Chan DePumpo

Tel: +1 (214) 593-9110
Fax: +1 (214) 593-9111

Shore Chan DePumpo, 901 Main Street

Plaintiff

Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC NPE (Patent Assertion Entity)

Represented By

11 Attorneys Listed

Daniel Scardino

Reed & Scardino LLP

Tel: +1 (512) 474-2449
Fax: +1 (512) 474-2622

301 Congress Ave, Ste 1250

Steven Tepera

Reed & Scardino LLP

Tel: +1 (512) 474-2449
Fax: +1 (512) 474-2622

301 Congress Ave, Suite 1250, Austin, TX 78701

Raymond William Mort , III

The Mort Law Firm, PLLC - Austin

Tel: +1 (512) 865-7950
Fax: +1 (512) 865-7950

100 Congress Ave, Suite 2200, Austin, TX 78701

Nicholas Andrew Wyss

Reed & Scardino LLP

Tel: +1 (512) 474-2449
Fax: +1 (512) 474-2622

301 Congress Ave, Suite 1250, Austin, TX 78701

Kyle Nicholas Harter

Reed & Scardino LLP

Tel: +1 (512) 279-7915
Fax: +1 (512) 474-2622

301 Congress Ave, Suite 1250

Ian Edward Cohen

Reed & Scardino LLP

Tel: +1 (512) 474-2449
Fax: +1 (512) 474-2662

301 Congress Ave, Suite 1250, Austin, TX 78701

Dustin Lee Taylor

Husch Blackwell LLP - Chicago

Tel: +1 (312) 526-1517
Fax: +1 (312) 655-1501

120 S Riverside Plaza, 22nd Floor

Deron R Dacus

The Dacus Firm, PC

Tel: +1 (903) 705-1117
Fax: +1 (903) 581-2543

821 ESE Loop 323, Suite 430

Craig Steven Jepson

Toler Law Group, PC

Tel: +1 (512) 327-5515
Fax: +1 (512) 327-5575

8500 Bluffstone Cove, Ste A201

Catherine Bentley Harris

Reed & Scardino LLP

Tel: +1 (512) 474-2449
Fax: +1 (512) 474-2622

301 Congress Ave, Suite 1250, Austin, TX 78701

Anthony D'Ascenzo Seach

Reed & Scardino LLP

Tel: +1 (512) 474-2449
Fax: +1 (512) 474-2622

301 Congress Ave, Suite 1250, Austin, TX 78701

Consol Defendant

HTC America, Inc. Operating Company

Represented By

8 Attorneys Listed

Trampas Alan Kurth

Patterson & Sheridan LLP - Dallas

Tel: +1 (214) 296-0157
Fax: +1 (713) 623-4846

1700 Pacific, Suite 2650

Susan Elizabeth Powley

Patterson & Sheridan LLP - Dallas

Tel: +1 (214) 296-0156
Fax: +1 (214) 302-0471

1700 Pacific, Suite 2650

Nathan Robert Curtis

Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLC - Dallas

Tel: +1 (214) 698-3423
Fax: +1 (214) 571-2961

Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLC - Dallas, 2100 McKinney Ave

Mark Andrew Perry

Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP - Washington

Tel: +1 (202) 887-3667
Fax: +1 (202) 530-9696

1050 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 300

Harry Lee Gillam , Jr

Gillam & Smith, LLP

Tel: +1 (903) 934-8450
Fax: +1 (903) 934-9257

303 South Washington Avenue, Marshall, TX 75670

Brian M Buroker

Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP - Washington

Tel: +1 (202) 955-8541
Fax: +1 (202) 530-4200

1050 Connecticut Avenue NW, Suite 300

Bobby Lamb

Gillam & Smith, LLP

Tel: +1 (903) 934-8450
Fax: +1 (903) 934-9257

303 South Washington Avenue, Marshall, TX 75670

Jerry Robin Selinger

Patterson & Sheridan LLP - Dallas

Tel: +1 (214) 272-0957
Fax: +1 (214) 296-0246

1700 Pacific, Suite 2650

Technical Advisor

David Keyzer NPE (Individual / Inventor)

Represented By

1 Attorneys Listed

David Keyzer

5170 Golden Foothill Parkway

Tel: +1 (916) 243-5259

5170 Golden Foothill Parkway, El Dorado Hills, CA 95762

Court & Judges

Court

District Court, E.D. Texas (txed)

Global Patent Family Cross-Litigation Radar

CasLoc 360° Radar

Multi-jurisdiction dispute tracking across USPTO PTAB, U.S. Federal Courts, Unified Patent Court (UPC), and EPO Oppositions

🇺🇸
U.S. District Courts 3 proceedings
🏛️
USPTO PTAB Trials 7 proceedings
🇪🇺
Unified Patent Court (UPC) Counterparts in force
🇩🇪
European Patent Office (EPO) Counterparts in force
Worldwide Family Members (1): 🇺🇸 US
Parallel Proceedings Across Jurisdictions (10 found):
PTAB: 7 U.S. Courts: 3
USPTO PTAB Trial 2016-12-30
IPR2017-00559

Google Inc. v. Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC

U.S. Continuation Sibling (5809428)
Status: Terminated-Settled
USPTO PTAB Trial 2016-12-30
IPR2017-00529

Google Inc. v. Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC

U.S. Continuation Sibling (5809428)
Status: Terminated-Settled
USPTO PTAB Trial 2016-12-30
IPR2017-00530

Google Inc. v. Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC

U.S. Continuation Sibling (5809428)
Status: Terminated-Settled
USPTO PTAB Trial 2016-12-29
IPR2017-00537

Google Inc. v. Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC

Asserted Patent
Status: Terminated-Settled
USPTO PTAB Trial 2016-12-29
IPR2017-00536

Google Inc. v. Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC

Asserted Patent
Status: Terminated-Settled
USPTO PTAB Trial 2016-08-11
IPR2016-01576

Microsoft Corporation v. Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC

Asserted Patent
Status: Terminated
USPTO PTAB Trial 2016-08-11
IPR2016-01581

Microsoft Corporation v. Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC

Asserted Patent
Status: Terminated
U.S. District Court 2013-11-07
2:13-cv-00947

Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC v. LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc.

Asserted Patent
Status: TXED
U.S. District Court 2012-12-31
2:12-cv-00832

Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC v. Sprint Nextel Corporation

Asserted Patent
Status: TXED
U.S. District Court 2012-09-14
1:12-cv-03222

Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC v. United Parcel Service, Inc.

Asserted Patent
Status: GAND
Stay ahead of cross-border rulings. Subscribe for free automated docket alerts across U.S. Courts, PTAB, UPC, and EPO.

Standard Essential Patent (SEP) & FRAND Intelligence

5G SEP • ETSI Declared High-Probability SEP Action

Essential standard specifications, SSO declaration status, and FRAND antitrust defense evaluation

FRAND Encumbered
Essential Standard 5G NR Generation: 5G
Standard Setting Org (SSO) ETSI / 3GPP Essential specification under ETSI / 3GPP governance
FRAND Commitment Committed Fair, Reasonable & Non-Discrim.
Known Patent Pools Avanci / Sisvel / Via Licensing Coverage Applicable Declarant: Zte

Injunction Restrictions & FRAND Defense Leverage (CJEU Huawei v. ZTE Framework)

Permanent Injunction Restricted

Asserted by recognized SEP declarant. Under the CJEU Huawei v. ZTE test, injunctions are barred if the defendant qualifies as a willing licensee.

✓ Patentee bound by SSO IPR Policy (ETSI Annex 6 / IEEE Patent Policy).
✓ Right to demand global FRAND portfolio determination.
✓ Non-discrimination defense: check licensing terms offered to competing implementers.

Patents Involved

2 Patents

There are 2 patents involved in this case.

Patent Asset Filing & Issue Date Expiration & Term Status External Links
US5809428
Method and device for processing undelivered data messages in a two-way wireless communications system
Filed: 1996-07-25
Issued: 1998-09-15
Expired (Term Ended)
Expires: 2016-07-25
US5754946
Nationwide communication system
Filed: 1993-09-21
Issued: 1998-05-19
Expired (Term Ended)
Expires: 2013-09-21

Patent Enforceability & Injunction Risk Assessment

Statutory Analysis
Injunction Viability (35 U.S.C. § 283) Statutorily Barred

Statutorily Barred — Patent expired. Under 35 U.S.C. § 283, courts cannot grant an injunction once a patent's term concludes. Litigation is restricted exclusively to past damages lookback.

Terminal Disclaimer & Cellect Risk Low Risk

Standard Statutory Term — No obviousness-type double patenting truncation noted.

Damages Lookback Horizon 6-Yr Max Lookback

Under 35 U.S.C. § 286, damages cannot accrue for infringement prior to 6 years before filing. All Statutory Maintenance Fees Paid (12-Year Window Cleared).

Procedural Motions & Interlocutory Orders

Motion Intelligence

Total Motions

93

Dispositive

18

Granted

11

Denied

1

Pending / Review

81

Motions by Category

Procedural / Extension Motion 21 Motion to Dismiss 11 Motion to Strike / Sanctions 16 Motion to Stay 2 Claim Construction / Markman Filing 18 Motion for Summary Judgment (Rule 56) 5 Motion to Compel Discovery 18 Motion for Summary Judgment (Infringement) 2

Key Dispositive Motions & Rulings

Motion for Summary Judgment (Rule 56) Pending / Under Review
SEALED PATENT SUR-REPLY re [176] HTC AMERICA'S SEALED PATENT MOTION for Summary Judgment on Licenses and Marking, filed by Mobile Telecommunications Technologie...
Entry #219 • 2016-06-27 Document →
Motion for Summary Judgment (Infringement) Pending / Under Review
SEALED PATENT SUR-REPLY re [170] HTC America, Inc.'s SEALED PATENT MOTION For Partial Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement, filed by Mobile Telecommunications T...
Entry #221 • 2016-06-27 Document →
Motion for Summary Judgment (Rule 56) Pending / Under Review
PLAINTIFF'S SEALED RESPONSE to [176] HTC AMERICA, INC.'S SEALED MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, filed by Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC. (Attachments:...
Entry #191 • 2016-06-06 Document →
Motion for Summary Judgment (Infringement) Pending / Under Review
PLAINTIFF'S SEALED RESPONSE to [170] HTC AMERICA, INC.'S SEALED MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF NON-INFRINGEMENT, filed by Mobile Telecommunications Tech...
Entry #192 • 2016-06-06 Document →
Motion for Summary Judgment (Rule 56) Pending / Under Review
SEALED PATENT ADDITIONAL ATTACHMENTS to [181] MTel's Sealed Patent Response to HTC's Motion for Summary Judgment. Exhibit 21. (Attachments: # (1) Exhibit 22, # ...
Entry #183 • 2016-06-04 Document →
Motion for Summary Judgment (Rule 56) Pending / Under Review
SEALED PATENT ADDITIONAL ATTACHMENTS to [181] MTel's Sealed Patent Response to HTC's Motion for Summary Judgment. Declaration of Raymond W. Mort, III in Support...
Entry #182 • 2016-06-03 Document →

Docket Entries

(240 total)
Pleading / Complaint

COMPLAINT against ZTE (USA), Inc. ( Filing fee $ 400 receipt number 0540-4395691.), filed by Mobile Telecommunications Technologies, LLC. (Attachments: # (1) Civil Cover Sheet, # (2) Exhibit A - US Patent 5809428, # (3) Exhibit B - US Patent 5754946)(Scardino, Daniel)

Entry #1 • 2013-11-07
1
Court Order Referred to Magistrate

ORDER REFERRING CASE to Magistrate Judge Roy S. Payne. Signed by Judge Rodney Gilstrap on 11/8/2013. (ch, )

Entry #2 • 2013-11-08
1

SUMMONS Issued as to ZTE (USA), Inc.. (ehs, )

Entry #3 • 2013-11-08
1

NOTICE of Attorney Appearance by Jennifer Marie Rynell on behalf of ZTE (USA), Inc. (Rynell, Jennifer)

Entry #4 • 2013-12-16
1

NOTICE of Attorney Appearance by Wei Wei on behalf of ZTE (USA), Inc. (Wei, Wei)

Entry #5 • 2013-12-16
1

Track Case Updates

Automated email notifications for new filings & decisions

Identifier: •

Free service • 1-click unsubscribe anytime • Powered by CasLoc