CasLoc logo
All Cases PTAB Litigations UPC Oppositions

Sam's West Inc. v. BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc.

6:22-cv-00587

Overview

Case Number 6:22-cv-00587
Filing Date 2022-03-22
Status Terminated
Termination Date 2023-02-02
Court District Court, M.D. Florida (flmd)
Nature of Suit 830 Patent
Jurisdiction Type Federal Question
Cause of Action 35:271 Patent Infringement
Jury Demand Plaintiff

Parties

Defendant

BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. NPE (Patent Assertion Entity)

Represented By

9 Attorneys Listed

Rex W. Miller , II

Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease LLP

Tel: +1 (617) 750-1653
Fax: +1 (614) 464-6350

52 East Gay Street, P.O. Box 1008

Mitchell Aaron Tobias

Vorys Sayer Seymour & Pease LLP

Tel: +1 (614) 464-6214
Fax: +1 (614) 719-4627

52 East Gay Street, PO Box 1008

Michael V. Messinger

Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease LLP

Tel: +1 (202) 467-8843

1909 K Street NW, Suite 900

Michael J. Garvin

Vorys Sayer Seymour & Pease LLP

Tel: +1 (216) 479-6100
Fax: +1 (216) 479-6060

200 Public Square, Suite 1400

Emily J. Taft

The Wendy's Company

Tel: +1 (970) 232-5055

The Wendy's Company, Legal Department

Alycia N. Broz

Vorys Sayer Seymour & Pease LLP

Tel: +1 (614) 464-5481
Fax: +1 (614) 719-4810

52 East Gay Street, P. O. Box 1008

Aaron M. Williams

Vorys Sayer Seymour & Pease LLP

Tel: +1 (216) 479-6180

200 Public Square, Suite 1400

William H. Oldach , III

Vorys Sayer Seymour & Pease LLP

Tel: +1 (202) 467-8880

1909 K Street, N.W., Suite 9th Floor

Liana Hollingsworth

Vorys Sayer Seymour and Pease LLP

Tel: +1 (216) 479-6152
Fax: +1 (216) 937-3406

200 Public Square, Suite 1400

Plaintiff

Walmart Apollo, LLC Operating Company

Represented By

13 Attorneys Listed

Suresh S. Rav

Wolf Greenfield & Sacks, PC

Tel: +1 (617) 646-8000
Fax: +1 (617) 646-8646

600 Atlantic Avenue, Boston, MA 02210

John W. Custer

Wolf Greenfield & Sacks, PC

Tel: +1 (617) 646-8000

600 Atlantic Avenue, Boston, MA 02210

Eric C. Reed

111 W Jefferson Street

Tel: +1 (407) 710-9950

111 W Jefferson Street, Suite 100

Elizabeth A. DiMarco

Wolf Greenfield & Sacks, PC

Tel: +1 (617) 646-8000

600 Atlantic Avenue, Boston, MA 02210

Charles Alan Lawson

Lawson Huck Gonzalez, PLLC

Tel: +1 (850) 825-4334

101 E. College Avenue, Suite 5th Floor

Joel Chao-Iee Lin

Gish PLLC

Tel: +1 (212) 518-2865

41 Madison Ave, Suite Floor 31

Isaku Begert

Dla Piper

Tel: +1 (312) 368-4053

Dla Piper, 444 W Lake St

Benjamin Yaghoubian

Dorsey & Whitney LLP

Tel: +1 (714) 800-1400

600 Anton Boulevard, Costa Mesa, CA 92626

Patrick S. Park

Hawkinson Yang LLP

Tel: +1 (213) 636-1976

8033 W. Sunset Blvd., Suite 3300

Henry Richard Fildes

DLA Piper LLP US

Tel: +1 (202) 799-4309
Fax: +1 (202) 799-5309

500 Eighth Street, NW, Washington, DC 20004

Ardith Bronson

DLA Piper LLP (US)

Tel: +1 (305) 423-8562
Fax: +1 (305) 503-9583

200 South Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 2500

Kathryn Riley Grasso

DLA Piper LLP (US)

Tel: +1 (202) 799-4000
Fax: +1 (202) 799-5215

500 Eighth Street, NW, Washington, DC 20004

Christian Chessman

DLA Piper LLP US

Tel: +1 (650) 833-2112
Fax: +1 (650) 687-1141

2000 University Avenue, East Palo Alto, CA 94303-2214

Sam's West, Inc. Operating Company

Represented By

13 Attorneys Listed

Suresh S. Rav

Wolf Greenfield & Sacks, PC

Tel: +1 (617) 646-8000
Fax: +1 (617) 646-8646

600 Atlantic Avenue, Boston, MA 02210

John W. Custer

Wolf Greenfield & Sacks, PC

Tel: +1 (617) 646-8000

600 Atlantic Avenue, Boston, MA 02210

Eric C. Reed

111 W Jefferson Street

Tel: +1 (407) 710-9950

111 W Jefferson Street, Suite 100

Elizabeth A. DiMarco

Wolf Greenfield & Sacks, PC

Tel: +1 (617) 646-8000

600 Atlantic Avenue, Boston, MA 02210

Charles Alan Lawson

Lawson Huck Gonzalez, PLLC

Tel: +1 (850) 825-4334

101 E. College Avenue, Suite 5th Floor

Joel Chao-Iee Lin

Gish PLLC

Tel: +1 (212) 518-2865

41 Madison Ave, Suite Floor 31

Isaku Begert

Dla Piper

Tel: +1 (312) 368-4053

Dla Piper, 444 W Lake St

Benjamin Yaghoubian

Dorsey & Whitney LLP

Tel: +1 (714) 800-1400

600 Anton Boulevard, Costa Mesa, CA 92626

Patrick S. Park

Hawkinson Yang LLP

Tel: +1 (213) 636-1976

8033 W. Sunset Blvd., Suite 3300

Henry Richard Fildes

DLA Piper LLP US

Tel: +1 (202) 799-4309
Fax: +1 (202) 799-5309

500 Eighth Street, NW, Washington, DC 20004

Ardith Bronson

DLA Piper LLP (US)

Tel: +1 (305) 423-8562
Fax: +1 (305) 503-9583

200 South Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 2500

Kathryn Riley Grasso

DLA Piper LLP (US)

Tel: +1 (202) 799-4000
Fax: +1 (202) 799-5215

500 Eighth Street, NW, Washington, DC 20004

Christian Chessman

DLA Piper LLP US

Tel: +1 (650) 833-2112
Fax: +1 (650) 687-1141

2000 University Avenue, East Palo Alto, CA 94303-2214

Court & Judges

Court

District Court, M.D. Florida (flmd)

Global Patent Family Cross-Litigation Radar

CasLoc 360° Radar 24 Family Members

Multi-jurisdiction dispute tracking across USPTO PTAB, U.S. Federal Courts, Unified Patent Court (UPC), and EPO Oppositions

🇺🇸
U.S. District Courts Counterparts in force
🏛️
USPTO PTAB Trials 1 proceeding
🇪🇺
Unified Patent Court (UPC) Counterparts in force
🇩🇪
European Patent Office (EPO) Counterparts in force
Worldwide Family Members (24): 🇨🇦 Canada CN GB 🇯🇵 Japan 🇺🇸 US 🌐 PCT
Parallel Proceedings Across Jurisdictions (1 found):
PTAB: 1
USPTO PTAB Trial 2022-09-07
IPR2022-01509

BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. v. Walmart Apollo, LLC

U.S. Continuation Sibling (10368188)
Status: Final Written Decision
Stay ahead of cross-border rulings. Subscribe for free automated docket alerts across U.S. Courts, PTAB, UPC, and EPO.

Patents Involved

4 Patents

There are 4 patents involved in this case.

Patent Asset Filing & Issue Date Expiration & Term Status External Links
US10121133
Method for self-checkout with a mobile device
Filed: 2010-11-16
Issued: 2018-11-06
Active (4.0 yrs remaining)
Expires: 2030-11-16
US10368187
Systems and methods for identifying available location-based services
Filed: 2017-12-07
Issued: 2019-07-30
Active (11.0 yrs remaining)
Expires: 2037-12-07
US10368188
Systems and methods for identifying location-based services
Filed: 2017-12-07
Issued: 2019-07-30
Active (11.1 yrs remaining) +5d PTA
Expires: 2037-12-12
US10803435
Method for self-checkout with a mobile device
Filed: 2019-12-30
Issued: 2020-10-13
Active (13.1 yrs remaining)
Expires: 2039-12-30

Patent Enforceability & Injunction Risk Assessment

Statutory Analysis
Injunction Viability (35 U.S.C. § 283) Active Threat

Active Threat — Patent is within enforceable statutory term; injunctive relief viable.

Terminal Disclaimer & Cellect Risk Low Risk

Standard Statutory Term — No obviousness-type double patenting noted.

Damages Lookback Horizon 6-Yr Max Lookback

Under 35 U.S.C. § 286, damages cannot accrue for infringement prior to 6 years before filing. 4th & 8th Year Maintenance Fees Paid (12th Year Window Upcoming).

Procedural Motions & Interlocutory Orders

Motion Intelligence

Total Motions

57

Dispositive

34

Granted

8

Denied

4

Pending / Review

28

Motions by Category

Motion for Preliminary Injunction / TRO 12 Procedural / Extension Motion 13 Motion to Dismiss (FRCP 12(b)(6)) 10 Motion to Dismiss 7 Motion to Compel Discovery 4 Claim Construction / Markman Filing 3 Motion to Stay Pending IPR / Reexam 5 Motion to Stay 3

Key Dispositive Motions & Rulings

Motion to Stay Pending IPR / Reexam Pending / Under Review
TRANSCRIPT of Hearing re: 91 Defendant BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc.'s Motion to Stay Proceedings Pending Inter Partes Review held on 11/01/2022 before Jud...
Entry #117 • 2023-03-18 Document →
Motion to Dismiss Denied
ORDER denying without prejudice 54 Motion to Dismiss; adopting 109 Report and Recommendations. The Clerk is directed to administratively close the case. Signed ...
Entry #114 • 2023-02-02 Document →
Motion to Dismiss (FRCP 12(b)(6)) Pending / Under Review
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re 54 MOTION to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim filed by BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. It is RECOMMENDED that the motion be...
Entry #109 • 2022-11-21 Document →
Motion to Dismiss Denied
ENDORSED ORDER denying without prejudice 85 Motion to Compel discovery. The Court has, by Order of even date, stayed this action pending a determination by the ...
Entry #110 • 2022-11-21 Document →
Motion to Stay Pending IPR / Reexam Pending / Under Review
Minute Entry. Virtual Proceedings held before Magistrate Judge David A. Baker: MOTION HEARING held on 11/1/2022 re 91 MOTION to Stay Proceedings Pending Inter P...
Entry #104 • 2022-11-01 Document →
Motion to Stay Pending IPR / Reexam Pending / Under Review
NOTICE of hearing on motion re 91 MOTION to Stay Proceedings Pending Inter Partes Review. Motion Hearing set for 11/1/2022 at 11:00 AM via Zoom Video Conference...
Entry #100 • 2022-10-21 Document →

Docket Entries

(226 total)
Motion for Preliminary Injunction / TRO

COMPLAINT and Demand for Jury Trial and Injunctive Relief against BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. with Jury Demand (Filing fee $402 receipt number AFLMDC-19371112) filed by Sam's West Inc., Walmart Apollo, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Civil Cover Sheet, # 10 Proposed Summons)(Bronson, Ardith) Modified on 3/23/2022 to correct docket text (BD). (Entered: 03/22/2022)

Entry #1 • 2022-03-22
1
Motion for Preliminary Injunction / TRO

COMPLAINT and Demand for Jury Trial and Injunctive Relief against BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. with Jury Demand (Filing fee $402 receipt number AFLMDC-19371112) filed by Sam's West Inc., Walmart Apollo, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Civil Cover Sheet, # 10 Proposed Summons)(Bronson, Ardith) Modified on 3/23/2022 to correct docket text (BD). (Entered: 03/22/2022)

Entry #1 • 2022-03-22
2
Motion for Preliminary Injunction / TRO

COMPLAINT and Demand for Jury Trial and Injunctive Relief against BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. with Jury Demand (Filing fee $402 receipt number AFLMDC-19371112) filed by Sam's West Inc., Walmart Apollo, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Civil Cover Sheet, # 10 Proposed Summons)(Bronson, Ardith) Modified on 3/23/2022 to correct docket text (BD). (Entered: 03/22/2022)

Entry #1 • 2022-03-22
2
Motion for Preliminary Injunction / TRO

COMPLAINT and Demand for Jury Trial and Injunctive Relief against BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. with Jury Demand (Filing fee $402 receipt number AFLMDC-19371112) filed by Sam's West Inc., Walmart Apollo, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Civil Cover Sheet, # 10 Proposed Summons)(Bronson, Ardith) Modified on 3/23/2022 to correct docket text (BD). (Entered: 03/22/2022)

Entry #1 • 2022-03-22
2
Motion for Preliminary Injunction / TRO

COMPLAINT and Demand for Jury Trial and Injunctive Relief against BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings, Inc. with Jury Demand (Filing fee $402 receipt number AFLMDC-19371112) filed by Sam's West Inc., Walmart Apollo, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Civil Cover Sheet, # 10 Proposed Summons)(Bronson, Ardith) Modified on 3/23/2022 to correct docket text (BD). (Entered: 03/22/2022)

Entry #1 • 2022-03-22
2

Track Case Updates

Automated email notifications for new filings & decisions

Identifier: •

Free service • 1-click unsubscribe anytime • Powered by CasLoc