CasLoc logo
All Cases PTAB Litigations UPC Oppositions

TuitionFund, LLC v. First Horizon National Corporation

3:11-cv-00852

Overview

Case Number 3:11-cv-00852
Filing Date 2011-09-08
Status Terminated
Termination Date 2014-02-12
Court District Court, M.D. Tennessee (tnmd)
Nature of Suit 830 Patent
Jurisdiction Type Federal Question
Cause of Action 35:271 Patent Infringement
Jury Demand Plaintiff

Parties

Movant

Branch Banking and Trust Company Operating Company

Represented By

8 Attorneys Listed

Erika N.D. Stanat

Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 231-1161
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Place, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Robert Jackson Walker

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Megan K. Dorritie

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

John C. Hayworth

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Anant Kishore

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Objector

Clayton Associates, LLC Operating Company

Represented By

1 Attorneys Listed

Kenneth Ray Jones , Jr.

Jones Hawkins & Farmer, PLC

Tel: +1 (615) 726-0050

Jones Hawkins & Farmer, PLC, One Nashville Place, Suite 1820

Defendant

Affinity Solutions, Inc. NPE (Patent Assertion Entity)

Represented By

8 Attorneys Listed

Erika N.D. Stanat

Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 231-1161
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Place, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Robert Jackson Walker

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Megan K. Dorritie

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

John C. Hayworth

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Anant Kishore

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

edo Interactive, Inc. Operating Company

Represented By

8 Attorneys Listed

William J. Lenz

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North LaSalle Street

Robert E. Browne

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Joshua Ray Denton

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin

Tel: +1 (615) 244-4994
Fax: +1 (615) 256-6339

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin, 150 Third Avenue South

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Terry L. Clark

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2951
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0798

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

Brian R. Iverson

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2954
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0792

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

BB&T Corporation NPE (Individual / Inventor)

Represented By

5 Attorneys Listed

Erika N.D. Stanat

Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 231-1161
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Place, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Robert Jackson Walker

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

John C. Hayworth

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Ally Financial, Inc. Operating Company

Represented By

6 Attorneys Listed

Joshua Ray Denton

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin

Tel: +1 (615) 244-4994
Fax: +1 (615) 256-6339

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin, 150 Third Avenue South

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Terry L. Clark

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2951
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0798

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

Brian R. Iverson

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2954
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0792

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

Ally Bank NPE (Individual / Inventor)

Represented By

6 Attorneys Listed

Joshua Ray Denton

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin

Tel: +1 (615) 244-4994
Fax: +1 (615) 256-6339

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin, 150 Third Avenue South

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Terry L. Clark

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2951
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0798

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

Brian R. Iverson

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2954
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0792

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

First Horizon National Corporation Operating Company

Represented By

8 Attorneys Listed

Erika N.D. Stanat

Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 231-1161
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Place, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Robert Jackson Walker

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Megan K. Dorritie

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

John C. Hayworth

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Anant Kishore

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Comerica Bank NPE (Individual / Inventor)

Represented By

9 Attorneys Listed

Brigid M. Carpenter

Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC (Nash)

Tel: +1 (615) 726-5600

211 Commerce Street, Suite 800

Erika N.D. Stanat

Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 231-1161
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Place, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Robert Jackson Walker

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Megan K. Dorritie

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

John C. Hayworth

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Anant Kishore

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

First Tennessee Bank National Association Operating Company

Represented By

8 Attorneys Listed

Erika N.D. Stanat

Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 231-1161
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Place, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Robert Jackson Walker

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Megan K. Dorritie

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

John C. Hayworth

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Anant Kishore

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Fiserv, Inc. Operating Company

Represented By

8 Attorneys Listed

Erika N.D. Stanat

Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 231-1161
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Place, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Robert Jackson Walker

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Megan K. Dorritie

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

John C. Hayworth

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Anant Kishore

Harter, Secrest & Emery, LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 232-6500

1600 Bausch & Lomb Plaza, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Fifth Third Bancorp NPE (Individual / Inventor)

Represented By

4 Attorneys Listed

Joshua Ray Denton

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin

Tel: +1 (615) 244-4994
Fax: +1 (615) 256-6339

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin, 150 Third Avenue South

Brian R. Iverson

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2954
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0792

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

Plaintiff

TuitionFund, LLC Operating Company

Represented By

12 Attorneys Listed

Scott P. Tift

Barrett Johnston Martin & Garrison, LLC

Tel: +1 (615) 244-2202
Fax: +1 (615) 252-3798

Barrett Johnston Martin & Garrison, LLC, Bank of America Plaza

David W. Garrison

Barrett Johnston Martin & Garrison, LLC

Tel: +1 (615) 244-2202
Fax: +1 (615) 252-3798

Barrett Johnston Martin & Garrison, LLC, Bank of America Plaza

Counter Claimant

Comerica Incorporated NPE (Individual / Inventor)

Represented By

6 Attorneys Listed

Brigid M. Carpenter

Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz, PC (Nash)

Tel: +1 (615) 726-5600

211 Commerce Street, Suite 800

Erika N.D. Stanat

Harter, Secrest & Emery LLP

Tel: +1 (585) 231-1161
Fax: +1 (585) 232-2152

1600 Bausch & Lomb Place, Rochester, NY 14604-2711

Robert Jackson Walker

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

John C. Hayworth

Butler Snow LLP (Nashville)

Tel: +1 (615) 651-6700
Fax: +1 (615) 651-6701

The Pinnacle at Symphony Place, 150 Third Avenue South

Fifth Third Bank NPE (Individual / Inventor)

Represented By

6 Attorneys Listed

Joshua Ray Denton

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin

Tel: +1 (615) 244-4994
Fax: +1 (615) 256-6339

Gullett, Sanford, Robinson & Martin, 150 Third Avenue South

Thomas J. Campbell

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg

Tel: +1 (312) 269-8000
Fax: +1 (312) 269-1747

Neal, Gerber & Eisenberg, Two North La Salle Street

Terry L. Clark

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2951
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0798

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

Brian R. Iverson

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC)

Tel: +1 (202) 827-2954
Fax: +1 (202) 478-0792

Bass, Berry & Sims (DC), 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue NW

Court & Judges

Court

District Court, M.D. Tennessee (tnmd)

Global Patent Family Cross-Litigation Radar

CasLoc 360° Radar 7 Family Members

Multi-jurisdiction dispute tracking across USPTO PTAB, U.S. Federal Courts, Unified Patent Court (UPC), and EPO Oppositions

🇺🇸
U.S. District Courts Counterparts in force
🏛️
USPTO PTAB Trials 5 proceedings
🇪🇺
Unified Patent Court (UPC) Counterparts in force
🇩🇪
European Patent Office (EPO) Counterparts in force
Worldwide Family Members (7): 🇺🇸 US
Parallel Proceedings Across Jurisdictions (5 found):
PTAB: 5
USPTO PTAB Trial 2014-01-08
CBM2014-00059

Cardlytics, Inc. v. TuitionFund, LLC

U.S. Continuation Sibling (7899704)
Status: Institution Denied
USPTO PTAB Trial 2014-01-08
CBM2014-00058

Cardlytics, Inc. v. TuitionFund, Inc

Asserted Patent
Status: Institution Denied
USPTO PTAB Trial 2013-12-05
CBM2014-00044

Edo Interactive, Inc. v. TuitionFund, LLC

U.S. Continuation Sibling (7899704)
Status: Institution Denied
USPTO PTAB Trial 2013-12-05
CBM2014-00043

Edo Interactive, Inc. v. TuitionFund, LLC

Asserted Patent
Status: Institution Denied
USPTO PTAB Trial 2013-12-05
CBM2014-00042

Edo Interactive, Inc. v. TuitionFund, LLC

U.S. Continuation Sibling (7499872)
Status: Terminated-Settled
Stay ahead of cross-border rulings. Subscribe for free automated docket alerts across U.S. Courts, PTAB, UPC, and EPO.

Patents Involved

3 Patents

There are 3 patents involved in this case.

Patent Asset Filing & Issue Date Expiration & Term Status External Links
US7499872
Methods and systems for applying rebates to higher education
Filed: 2000-11-01
Issued: 2009-03-03
Expired (Term Ended) +1205d PTA
Expires: 2024-02-19
US7653572
Methods and systems for providing a rebate program
Filed: 2008-12-31
Issued: 2010-01-26
Active (2.1 yrs remaining)
Expires: 2028-12-31
US7899704
Methods and systems for providing a merchant funded rebate program
Filed: 2009-12-30
Issued: 2011-03-01
Active (3.1 yrs remaining)
Expires: 2029-12-30

Patent Enforceability & Injunction Risk Assessment

Statutory Analysis
Injunction Viability (35 U.S.C. § 283) Statutorily Barred

Statutorily Barred — Patent expired. Under 35 U.S.C. § 283, injunctive relief is barred.

Terminal Disclaimer & Cellect Risk Scrutiny / Risk

High PTA (+1205 days) / In re Cellect scrutiny applies.

Damages Lookback Horizon 6-Yr Max Lookback

Under 35 U.S.C. § 286, damages cannot accrue for infringement prior to 6 years before filing. 4th Year Maintenance Fee Paid (8th Year Window Upcoming).

Procedural Motions & Interlocutory Orders

Motion Intelligence

Total Motions

40

Dispositive

34

Granted

4

Denied

0

Pending / Review

36

Motions by Category

Procedural / Extension Motion 3 Motion to Dismiss 30 Motion to Stay 3 Motion to Stay Pending IPR / Reexam 4

Key Dispositive Motions & Rulings

Motion to Dismiss Pending / Under Review
REPLY to Response re 99 MOTION to Dismiss filed by Affinity Solutions, Inc., BB&T Corporation, Branch Banking and Trust Company, Comerica Bank, Comerica Incorpo...
Entry #109 • 2012-02-17 Document →
Motion to Dismiss Pending / Under Review
REPLY to Response to re 102 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint filed by Ally Bank, Ally Financial, Inc., Fifth Third Bancorp, Fifth Third Ban...
Entry #110 • 2012-02-17 Document →
Motion to Dismiss Pending / Under Review
RESPONSE in Opposition re 99 MOTION to Dismiss PLAINTIFF TUITIONFUNDS RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS FIRST HORIZON NATIONAL CORPORATION; FIRST TENNESEE BANK NATIONAL AS...
Entry #107 • 2012-02-03 Document →
Motion to Dismiss Pending / Under Review
RESPONSE in Opposition re 102 MOTION to Dismiss Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint PLAINTIFF TUITIONFUNDS RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS EDO INTERACTIVE, ALLY FINANCIA...
Entry #108 • 2012-02-03 Document →
Motion to Dismiss Pending / Under Review
REPLY to Response to Motion re 70 MOTION to Dismiss for Lack of Personal Jurisdiction filed by BB&T Corporation, Comerica Incorporated. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibi...
Entry #98 • 2012-01-13 Document →
Motion to Dismiss Pending / Under Review
MOTION to Dismiss by Affinity Solutions, Inc., BB&T Corporation, Branch Banking and Trust Company, Comerica Bank, Comerica Incorporated, First Horizon National ...
Entry #99 • 2012-01-13 Document →

Docket Entries

(120 total)
Pleading / Complaint

COMPLAINT against Affinity Solutions, Inc., Ally Bank, Ally Financial, Inc., BB&T Corporation, Branch Banking and Trust Company, Comerica Bank, Comerica Incorporated, Fifth Third Bancorp, Fifth Third Bank, First Horizon National Corporation, First Tennessee Bank National Association, Fiserv, Inc., edo Interactive, Inc., filed by TuitionFund, LLC.Filing fee paid $350.Summons issued. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A- U.S. Patent 7499872 B1, # 2 Exhibit B-U.S. Patent 7653572 B1, # 3 Exhibit C-U.S. Patent 7899704 B1, # 4 Civil Cover Sheet, # 5 Summons)(eh) (Additional attachment(s) added on 9/9/2011: # 6 Summons) (afs). (Entered: 09/08/2011)

Entry #1 • 2011-09-08
1

NOTICE from USDC Clerk regarding Corporate Disclosure Statement requirement (eh) (Entered: 09/08/2011)

Entry #2 • 2011-09-08
1

NOTICE of Initial Case Management Conference set for 11/28/2011 at 02:30 PM in Chambers 825 before District Judge Aleta A. Trauger. (afs) (Entered: 09/09/2011)

Entry #3 • 2011-09-09
1
Court Order

ORDER REASSIGNING CASE. Judge Sharp and Judge Trauger have conferred and agreed that this case is a case related to an earlier-filed case assigned to him. Therefore, it is hereby ORDERED that the Clerk shall reassign this case to Judge Sharp pursuant to Administrative Order No. 176. It is so ORDERED. Case reassigned to District Judge Kevin H. Sharp for all further proceedings. District Judge Aleta A. Trauger no longer assigned to case. Signed by District Judge Aleta A. Trauger on 9/13/11. (tmw) (Entered: 09/13/2011)

Entry #4 • 2011-09-13
1
Court Order

ORDER: It appears that this action is related to another action filed in this Court. The earlier-filed of these actions was assigned to Judge Sharp and Judge Bryant. Following consultation with Judge Bryant, the instant matter is transferred to Judge Bryant for all Magistrate Judge proceedings and responsibilities. IT IS SO ORDERED. Signed by Magistrate Judge E. Clifton Knowles on 9/13/11. (tmw) (Entered: 09/13/2011)

Entry #5 • 2011-09-13
1

Track Case Updates

Automated email notifications for new filings & decisions

Identifier: •

Free service • 1-click unsubscribe anytime • Powered by CasLoc