Masimo Corporation vs. Apple Inc.

Explore the PTAB proceeding IPR2023-00728 filed by Masimo Corporation on 2023-03-16. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Proceeding Overview

Proceeding Number

IPR2023-00728

Filing Date

2023-03-16

Accorded Filing Date

2023-03-16

Institution Decision Date

2023-09-18

Last Modified Date

2024-04-11

Proceeding Type

IPR

Termination Date

2023-09-18

Trial Status

Institution Denied

Parties & Counsel

Petitioner

Masimo Corporation

Represented By

Wentzel, Douglaset al

Patent Owner / Respondent

Apple Inc.

Represented By

Renner, W. Karlet al

Tribunal & Venue

Tribunal

Patent Trial and Appeal Board (USPTO)

Technology Center

TC 2900 - Designs

Patent Information

1 Patent Involved

Respondent Application Number 29816025

Respondent Patent Number D962936

External Links

Espacenet

Google Patents

Respondent Inventor Jody AKANA et al

Respondent Tech Center TC 2900 - Designs

Address and Attorney/Agent Information

105 Registered Practitioners

Power of Attorney & Correspondence

Firm / Entity Name STERNE, KESSLER, GOLDSTEIN & FOX P.L.L.C.

Customer Number 63975

Address 1101 K Street, NW, 10th Floor, WASHINGTON, DC, 20005, UNITED STATES

Attorney / Agent Information

Reg #	Name	Phone
28912	Robert Sterne	202-772-8555
29021	Jorge Goldstein	202-371-2600
32831	Tracy-Gene Durkin	202-371-2600
33876	Donald Featherstone	202-772-8629
33997	Michael Ray	202-772-8569
34395	Robert Millonig	202-371-2600
35239	Michael Lee	703-628-0233
36013	Robert Sokohl	202-371-2600
36449	Susan Heminger	408-862-5906
36688	Eric Steffe	202-371-8625
38759	John Covert	202-371-2600
39967	Eldora Ellison	202-772-8508
41306	Timothy Shea Jr	202-371-2600
42289	Donald Banowit	202-371-2600
43447	Jason Eisenberg	202-371-2600
44252	Jeffrey Myers	408-974-0110
44757	Jeffrey Helvey	202-772-8675
45738	Quin Hoellwarth	208-922-3571
45871	Mark Rygiel	202-371-2600
45986	Peter Jackman	202-371-2600
47756	Gaby Longsworth	202-371-2600
48018	Richard Wohld	408-974-8738
50167	Leticia Block	408-974-5875
50720	Jon Wright	202-371-2600
52717	Chi-Hsin Chang	408-862-3597
52997	Arlen Hartounian	408-783-1802
53812	Daniel Yonan	202-371-2600
54179	Michelle Holoubek	202-772-8855
54463	Michael Specht	202-371-2600
55796	Sanjay Gadkari	408-783-9599
56374	Ross Hicks	202-371-2600
57460	Darrell Kinder Jr.	408-974-6473
57913	Paul Calvo	202-772-8846
58164	Kristina Kelly	202-776-5284
58403	Marsha Gillentine	202-772-8692
58803	Ali Shah	408-862-4362
58885	Matthew Bodenstein	202-772-8787
59391	Anthony Petro	512-657-0440
59425	Kyle Conklin	202-371-2600
60372	Lawrence Lu	408-783-4880
60390	Richard Coller Iii	202-772-8764
60607	Chandrika Vira	202-772-8672
60889	Salvador Bezos	202-772-8533
61205	David Holman	202-371-2600
61327	Jonathan Tuminaro	202-371-2600
61825	Shant Tchakerian	760-814-1738
61868	Dennies Varughese	202-772-8805
62085	Cameron Pilling	206-359-8000
62732	Deborah Sterling	202-772-8501
63128	Jia Wu	858-651-4207
63285	Joseph Mutschelknaus	202-371-2600
63504	Ralph Powers Iii	202-772-8876
63851	Brian Wacter	669-227-3892
64228	Graham Phero	202-772-8860
64515	Daniel Gajewski	202-772-8774
64587	Syed Ahmed	847-289-5228
64681	Adam Larock	212-218-2507
64974	Michael Gross Iii	202-772-8762
65021	Christian Camarce	202-772-8895
65172	Byron Pickard	202-371-2600
65367	Jason Fitzsimmons	202-772-8701
65409	Ryan Sydenham	408-783-4920
65457	Lauren Schleh	703-836-6400
65486	Chad Himeda	650-813-5727
65825	Nikhil Sriraman	312-316-0357
65865	Joshua Olson	408-974-6064
66638	Jeremiah Frueauf	202-772-8506
67254	Ryan Richardson	202-772-8729
67443	Euborn Chiu	925-389-6681
67592	Stephanie Grosvenor	703-205-8034
67836	Bonnie Nannenga-Combs	202-371-2600
67936	Ming-Yuh Hsu	408-783-2678
68395	Daniel Block	202-371-2600
68504	Ji Eun Kim	202-371-2600
68658	Richard Bemben	202-371-2600
68887	Amirali Sharifi	202-772-8871
69105	Nirav Desai	202-371-2600
69235	Karen Wong-Chan	202-772-8647
70524	Dohm Chankong	202-772-8529
71185	Rebekah Holtz	202-772-8712
71624	Eric Bernsen	619-944-4720
71909	Josephine Kim	949-422-1586
72274	Kiranjit Dhaliwal	408-111-1111
72314	Lestin Kenton Jr.	202-772-8594
72488	Yuke Wang	214-284-3876
72567	Todd Hopfinger	202-772-8696
73112	David Haars	202-371-2600
73287	Charles Hammond	202-772-8551
73418	Stephen Mao	650-326-2400
73904	Steven Pappas	202-772-8719
74290	Ian Soule	202-772-8984
74533	Alexander Covington	202-772-8749
74612	Ivy Clarice Estoesta	202-772-8686
74737	Hyung Myung	858-207-0359
75069	Tyler Dutton	202-772-8982
75187	Timothy Tang	202-772-8758
75269	Roozbeh Gorgin	202-772-8667
75402	Peiling Zhang	503-595-5300
76928	Hasina Ali	202-772-8978
77776	Zhichun Zhang	202-772-8813
78365	Wenhao Xiong	202-772-8615
79290	Michael Webb	202-772-8834
81041	Xiaowei Jin	202-772-8752
81654	Payton Miles	202-772-1276
83022	Jean Selep	202-772-1270

Proceeding Documents

Notice: refund approved NOTICE

2024-04-11 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Petitioner's Request for Refund of Post-Institution Fees OTHER

2024-04-08 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Rehearing: DECISION Denying Petitioner’s Request on Rehearing of Decision Denying Institution 37 C.F.R. § 42.71(d) REHEARING

2024-01-11 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

1053

FedCirBlog, En Banc Petitions Exhibit

2023-10-18 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1058

Brief For the United States as Amicus Curiae on Rehearing En Banc in Support of Neither Party Exhibit

2023-10-18 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Masimo Corporation vs. Apple Inc.

Proceeding Overview

Parties & Counsel

Petitioner

Masimo Corporation

Represented By

Patent Owner / Respondent

Apple Inc.

Represented By

Tribunal & Venue

Patent Information

Address and Attorney/Agent Information

Power of Attorney & Correspondence

Attorney / Agent Information

Proceeding Documents

Notice: refund approved NOTICE

Petitioner's Request for Refund of Post-Institution Fees OTHER

Rehearing: DECISION Denying Petitioner’s Request on Rehearing of Decision Denying Institution 37 C.F.R. § 42.71(d) REHEARING

FedCirBlog, En Banc Petitions Exhibit

Brief For the United States as Amicus Curiae on Rehearing En Banc in Support of Neither Party Exhibit

Cutala, Federal Circuit Set to Rehear Case En Banc Impacting the Longstanding Test for Design Patent Obviousness Exhibit

FedCirBlog, Click-to-Call Technologies, LP v. Ingenio, Inc. Exhibit

Wells, Is Federal Circuit on the verge of upending harmonious co-existence between design patents and utility patents? Exhibit

Bell, Two Years in Review: Rehearing Petitions in Patent Cases Exhibit

Petitioner Updated Exhibit List NOTICE

Petitioner's Request for Rehearing REHEARING

McDermott, Full Federal Circuit to Review Challenge to Test for Design Patent Obviousness Exhibit

DECISION Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314 DECISION

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response OTHER

Declaration of Lance Gordon Rake Exhibit

Aries Watches Watch AW80 Exhibit

P11 Plus Watch Exhibit

Replacement Drawings_U.S. Design Application 29/816,024 Exhibit

Petitioner's Sotera Stipulation OTHER

Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corporation, et al., Scheduling Order, No. 1:22- cv-01377 (D. Del.) Exhibit

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE

Patent Owners Mandatory Notice NOTICE

Patent Owners Power of Attorney NOTICE

Notice: Notice filing date accorded NOTICE

File History of U.S. Patent No. D962,936 Exhibit

Mendelson, “Measurement Site and Photodetector Size Considerations" Exhibit

Chinese Design Reg. No. 303285726 Exhibit

U.S. Pat. Appl. Pub. No. 2019/0196411 (“Yuen”) Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 10,610,157 (“’157 patent”) Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 6,265,789 Exhibit

Public Excerpt, Malackowski Decl ISO Apple Mtn for Expedited Trial (D. Del) Exhibit

Petitioner's Power of Attorney NOTICE

Apple Watch Series 4 Teardown, https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. D782,537 Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 10,945,648 Exhibit

Public Excerpts of Apple 6-6-22 Opening Presentation, ITC Inv. 337-TA-1276 Exhibit

Mendelson, “A Wearable Reflectance Pulse Oximeter" (2006) Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 10,912,502 Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 10,912,501 Exhibit

Jung, “Medgadget Joins the Verily Baseline ProjectStudy, Part 2 Exhibit

Apple Watch Magnetic Charging Cable (1 m) Exhibit

Curriculum Vitae of Joel Delman Exhibit

Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., Complaint, No. 1:22-cv-01377 (D. Del.) Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. D735,131 Exhibit

Curriculum Vitae of R. James Duckworth, Ph.D. Exhibit

Excerpts of Warren Expert Report, Masimo v. Apple, No. 8:20-cv-48 (CD Cal.) Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 6,091,530 (“Duckworth”) Exhibit

Public Excerpts, Final ID on Violation of Section 337, ITC Inv. 337-TA-1276 Exhibit

“Apple Watch Series 4 – Health,” from apple.com/apple-watch-series-4/health Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. D827,831 (“Fong”) Exhibit

Declaration of R. James Duckworth, Ph.D. Exhibit

Konig et al., Reflectance Pulse Oximetry (1998) Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 6,075,755 (“Zarchan”) Exhibit

Mendelson, Invasive and Noninvasive Blood Gas Monitoring Exhibit

“Charge Apple Watch,” from https://support.apple.com/guide Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 6,801,799 (“Mendelson”) Exhibit

Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent No. D962,936 PETITION

Declaration of Joel Delman Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. D816,524 Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. 10,627,783 (“’783 patent”) Exhibit

U.S. Pat. Appl. Pub. No. 2017/0086743 (“Bushnell”) Exhibit

Masimo Opp to Apple Mtn for Expedited Trial, 1:22-cv-01377 (D. Del.) Exhibit

June 6-10, 2022 Public Hearing Transcript, ITC Inv. No 337-TA-1276 Exhibit

U.S. Pat. No. D753,510 Exhibit

PCT Appl. Pub. No. WO 2017/165532 (“Paulke”) Exhibit