Nintendo Co., Ltd. et al. vs. Polaris PowerLED Technologies, LLC
Explore the PTAB proceeding IPR2023-00778 filed by Nintendo Co., Ltd. et al. on 2023-03-28. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.
Proceeding Overview
Proceeding Number
IPR2023-00778
Filing Date
2023-03-28
Accorded Filing Date
2023-03-28
Institution Decision Date
2023-10-18
Last Modified Date
2024-08-16
Proceeding Type
IPR
Termination Date
2024-05-07
Trial Status
Terminated-Settled
Parties & Counsel
Petitioner
Nintendo Co., Ltd. et al.
Represented By
Brigham, Matthewet alPatent Owner / Respondent
Polaris PowerLED Technologies, LLC
Represented By
Tonkovich, Russellet alTribunal & Venue
Tribunal
Patent Trial and Appeal Board (USPTO)
Technology Center
TC 2600 - Communications
Patent Information
Address and Attorney/Agent Information
Power of Attorney & Correspondence
Attorney / Agent Information
| Reg # | Name | Phone |
|---|---|---|
| 31291 | Joseph Re | 949-760-0404 |
| 31430 | Craig Summers | 949-760-0404 |
| 32297 | Edward Schlatter | 949-760-0404 |
| 34115 | Daniel Altman | 949-760-0404 |
| 34362 | John King | 949-760-0404 |
| 35556 | Stephen Jensen | 949-760-0404 |
| 36516 | Michael Fuller | 858-707-4000 |
| 37688 | Steven Nataupsky | 949-760-0404 |
| 37924 | Raimond Salenieks | 858-707-4000 |
| 39287 | Joseph Mallon | 858-707-4000 |
| 39901 | Neil Bartfeld | 858-707-4202 |
| 40574 | Maria Anderson | 206-405-2000 |
| 40664 | Joseph Jennings | 949-760-0404 |
| 41371 | David Weiss | 310-551-3450 |
| 41394 | Adeel Akhtar | 415-954-4114 |
| 42610 | John Grover | 949-760-0404 |
| 43622 | Mark Gallagher | 949-760-0404 |
| 43745 | Sabing Lee | 949-760-0404 |
| 43878 | Joseph Reisman | 858-707-4000 |
| 44087 | Paul Conover | 949-760-0404 |
| 44328 | Melanie Seelig | 206-405-2000 |
| 45664 | Eric Furman | 858-707-4000 |
| 46206 | Mauricio Uribe | 206-405-2000 |
| 46547 | Matthew Bellinger | 949-760-0404 |
| 47677 | Bruce Itchkawitz | 949-760-0404 |
| 48877 | Curtis Huffmire | 949-760-0404 |
| 51212 | Andrew Douglas | 949-760-0404 |
| 51240 | Linda Liu | 949-760-0404 |
| 51241 | James Herkenhoff | 6503282844 |
| 51754 | Christy Green | 949-760-0404 |
| 51922 | Irfan Lateef | 949-721-7672 |
| 52082 | Perry Oldham | 949-721-2961 |
| 53018 | Gregory Hermanson | 858-707-4000 |
| 53084 | Mark Kachner | 310-551-3450 |
| 53102 | Benjamin Katzenellenbogen | (617) 499-6200 |
| 53317 | Andrew Merickel | 415-954-4114 |
| 53428 | Yichuan Pan | 858-707-4000 |
| 53658 | Sheila Swaroop | 949-760-0404 |
| 54198 | Russell Jeide | 949-760-0404 |
| 54511 | Josue Villalta | 949-760-0404 |
| 54618 | Karen Lenker | 949-760-0404 |
| 55030 | Cheryl Burgess | 949-721-2935 |
| 55036 | Ted Cannon | 949-760-0404 |
| 55310 | Agnes Juang | 949-760-0404 |
| 55634 | Raymond Smith | 949-760-0404 |
| 56553 | Lauren Keller | 949-721-6365 |
| 57046 | Jarom Kesler | 949-760-0404 |
| 57505 | Michael Christensen | 949-760-0404 |
| 57571 | Maria Stout | 858-707-4000 |
| 57871 | Mark Marsden | 858-707-4000 |
| 58474 | Jared Bunker | 949-760-0404 |
| 58621 | Ryan Melnick | 858-707-4000 |
| 58855 | Andrew Kimmel | 949-760-0404 |
| 59362 | Lincoln Essig | 202-640-6400 |
| 59406 | David Trossen | 415-954-4114 |
| 59856 | Terry Tullis | 949-760-0404 |
| 60295 | Brenden Gingrich | 858-707-4000 |
| 60934 | Christopher Ross | 949-760-0404 |
| 61224 | Carol Pitzel Cruz | 206-405-2000 |
| 61513 | Colin Heideman | 206-405-2000 |
| 61546 | Theodore Papagiannis | 949-760-0404 |
| 61557 | Nicholas Zovko | 949-760-0404 |
| 61569 | Qian Dai | 858-707-4000 |
| 61595 | Susan Natland | 949-760-0404 |
| 61749 | Kimberly Miller | 858-707-4000 |
| 61805 | Jason Jardine | 858-707-4000 |
| 62027 | Aaron Davis | 415-954-4114 |
| 62280 | Ian Gillies | 858-707-4000 |
| 62676 | Philip Nelson | 949-760-0404 |
| 62933 | Christie Matthaei | 206-405-2000 |
| 63035 | Kregg Koch | 310-551-3450 |
| 63051 | Brian Claassen | 949-760-0404 |
| 63106 | Chang Lim | 949-760-0404 |
| 63160 | Nathanael Luman | 858-836-9000 |
| 63635 | Alan Laquer | 949-760-0404 |
| 63934 | Jeffery Hallstrom | 949-760-0404 |
| 64096 | Joshua Stowell | 949-760-9562 |
| 64420 | Jason Swartz | 609/734-6888 |
| 64970 | Morgan Coates | 949-760-0404 |
| 65026 | Devanie Dufour | 202-640-6400 |
| 65066 | Scott Cromar | 949-721-2812 |
| 65157 | Laura Hall | 949-721-7686 |
| 65290 | Sean Ambrosius | 949-760-0404 |
| 65562 | Derek Dailey | 858-707-4000 |
| 65614 | Shannon Lam | 949-760-0404 |
| 65642 | Andrea Cheek | 202-640-6400 |
| 65994 | Marko Zoretic | 949-760-0404 |
| 66152 | Lance Smemoe | 949-760-0404 |
| 66226 | Derek Bayles | 949-760-0404 |
| 66385 | Joan Chan | 949-760-0404 |
| 66766 | Andrew Lloyd | 949-760-0404 |
| 67249 | Kyu Min | 415-954-4114 |
| 67720 | Salima Merani | 949-760-0404 |
| 67824 | Hochan Song | 949-760-0404 |
| 67884 | Jonathan Bachand | 202-640-6400 |
| 68005 | Vikas Bhargava | 949-760-0404 |
| 68069 | Vladislav Teplitskiy | 949-721-5308 |
| 68287 | Paul Stellman | 415-954-4114 |
| 68306 | William Adams | 949-760-0404 |
| 68316 | Jason Champion | 949-760-0404 |
| 68329 | Daniel Gibson | 949-760-0404 |
| 68430 | Vladimir Lozan | 949-721-2828 |
| 68578 | Thomas Cowan | 858-707-4000 |
| 68587 | Viswanathan Lakshmanan | 415-954-4114 |
| 69133 | Stephen Larson | 949-760-0404 |
| 69282 | Heungsoo Choi | 858-707-4000 |
| 70224 | Robert Hilton | 858-707-4000 |
| 70256 | Damien Howard | 949-760-0404 |
| 70367 | Adam Powell | 650-752-1100 |
| 70451 | Mark Rubinshtein | 858-707-4000 |
| 70611 | Karen Marie Cassidy | 949-721-5302 |
| 70780 | Bryan Mcwhorter | 206-405-2000 |
| 71099 | Justin Gillett | 949-760-0404 |
| 71587 | Hans Mayer | 949-760-0404 |
| 71679 | Daniel Kamkar | 858-707-4180 |
| 71691 | Makoto Tsunozaki | 415-954-4114 |
| 71933 | Jordan Gottdank | 858-707-4000 |
| 72423 | Brian Graham | 415-814-6161 |
| 72722 | Peter Law | 858-707-4243 |
| 73097 | Harnik Shukla | 949-760-0404 |
| 73126 | David Schmidt | 949-721-6386 |
| 74164 | Aaron Johnson | 949-395-4097 |
| 74752 | Aryeh Feinstein | 202-640-6408 |
| 74897 | Douglas Wentzel | 856-285-4688 |
| 74907 | Dominic Filice | 650-849-3061 |
| 75143 | Michelle Ziperstein | 310-407-3475 |
| 75150 | Clayton Henson | 858-707-4000 |
| 75231 | Paul Spiel | 206-405-2032 |
| 75319 | Alexander Martinez | 949-760-0404 |
| 75684 | Jessica Achtsam | 949-760-0404 |
| 75686 | Jeremy Anapol | 949-721-2806 |
| 75717 | Jeremy Carney | 949-760-0404 |
| 75733 | Katherine Mcmorrow | 310-407-3460 |
| 75805 | Brian Barnes | 949-721-5242 |
| 76047 | Inzer Ni | 212-849-3044 |
| 76130 | Tyler Cox | 415-217-3516 |
| 76238 | Mitchell Hadley | 212-849-3013 |
| 76314 | David Cohen | 949-760-0404 |
| 76416 | Spencer Carter | 949-760-0404 |
| 76592 | Daniel Hughes | 858-707-4000 |
| 76821 | Charles Choi | 718-807-5825 |
| 77014 | Justin Culbertson | 202-640-6400 |
| 77396 | Paige Radtke | 949-760-0404 |
| 77474 | Alistair Mcintyre | 858-707-4102 |
| 77499 | Samuel Cockriel | 949-760-0404 |
| 77806 | Nathan Reeves | 206-405-2000 |
| 77839 | Zachary Messick | 858-707-4000 |
| 78415 | Rhett Ramsey | 949-721-2932 |
| 78566 | Douglas Crandell | 858-707-4253 |
| 78620 | Brian Flynn | 858-707-4187 |
| 78677 | Kurt Jacobs | 949-721-2994 |
| 79031 | Christopher Lewis | 202-640-6433 |
| 79046 | Xiaoyan Wang | 949-760-0404 |
| 79108 | Lindsay Laddaran | 949-721-2893 |
| 79142 | Paige Cappelli | 202-640-6409 |
| 79146 | Serah Friedman | 310-825-1097 |
| 79242 | Joshua Martineau | 212-849-3000 |
| 79325 | Luke Holbrook | 949-721-2929 |
| 79474 | Yi-Ju Chen | 858-707-4000 |
| 79477 | Ryan Newell | 949-760-0404 |
| 79610 | Jose Martin Del Campo | 949-721-5340 |
| 79631 | Daniel Kiang | 949-760-0404 |
| 79683 | Eric Abada | 415-217-3515 |
| 79744 | Erin Cardinal | 202-640-6417 |
| 79750 | Daniel Mittelstein | 949-760-0404 |
| 79783 | Janet Allendorph | 858-707-4000 |
| 79806 | Charles Sirek | 949-760-0404 |
| 800049 | Po-An Chen | 949-721-2835 |
| 800099 | Jae Jin Lee | 212-849-3022 |
| 800104 | Rory Lootsma | 949-760-0404 |
| 800106 | Baiyu Zhu | 215-268-3871 |
| 800110 | Geetha Durairaj | 949-760-0404 |
| 80143 | Tomohisa Fujiwara | 858-707-4210 |
| 80189 | Michael Salamy | 858-225-3683 |
| 80326 | Ashley Morales | 858-707-4022 |
| 80584 | Zachary Grinovich | 949-760-0404 |
| 80623 | Gregory Munchinsky | 858-707-4000 |
| 80915 | Susan Janicki | 946-760-0404 |
| 80919 | Emmett Litvak | 91-124-280-6101 |
| 81154 | Dylan Kramer | 949-721-7679 |
| 81223 | Phillip Minnick | 858-707-4000 |
| 81514 | Ryan Freedman | 516-307-6947 |
| 81554 | Harper Beasley | 858-707-4014 |
| 81694 | Oren Rosenberg | 949-721-2928 |
| 81756 | Sophia Zahn | 914-792-8066 |
| 81888 | Justin Theam | 949-760-0404 |
| 81919 | Richard Witas | 120-264-06415 |
| 82102 | Jordan Deorio | 949-721-2840 |
| 82117 | Purna Chandrasekhar | 908-391-4940 |
| 82306 | Kathryn Mccarthy | 949-760-0404 |
| 82380 | Arash Pia | 949-721-5276 |
| 82485 | Mason Whisnant | 212-849-3060 |
| 82505 | James Raleigh | 121-284-93063 |
| 82574 | Bailey Arenberg | 949-760-0404 |
| 82614 | Zachary Greenberg | 347-266-1025 |
| 82708 | Jaeyoung Choi | 949-721-2810 |
| 82852 | Jacob Etling | 724-757-6817 |
| 82890 | Ningxi Sun | 858-707-4110 |
| 82901 | Cesar Estrada | 949-760-0404 |
| 82924 | Matthew Whitehead | 206-405-2041 |
| 83014 | Shawn Hickey | 206-405-2000 |
| 83062 | Sashank Krothapally | 415-217-8380 |
| 83091 | Shloka Raghavan | 858-707-4000 |
| 83096 | Kelsey Weinman | 949-760-0404 |
| 83166 | Raymond Lu | 969-760-2852 |
| 83383 | Jamal Perry | 212-849-3030 |
| L1081 | Stacy Rush | 646-575-6066 |
Proceeding Documents
123Notice: refund denied NOTICE
Petitioners' Request for Refund of Post Institution Fees OTHER
Termination Decision: Post-DI Settlement TERMINATE
Joint Motion to Terminate MOTION
Joint Motion to Terminate MOTION
Unopposed Request to Keep Confidential OTHER
Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Date 2 NOTICE
Petitioners' Notice of Deposition of Dr. Robert L. Stevenson NOTICE
EX2028 2023-11-17 NIRC Exhibit
EX2040 2023-01-12 Nintendo Preliminary CC Exhibit
EX2032 Baker Deposition Transcript Exhibit
EX2036 US7791694 Exhibit
EX2034 Renesas AN1422 Exhibit
EX2027 2023-08-02 Office Action Response Exhibit
EX2039 LX1971 Data Sheet Exhibit
EX2031 106 Polaris Op CC Brief Exhibit
EX2029 90_019119 Reexamination Certificate Exhibit
EX2033 EE Times - Making sense of light sensor Exhibit
EX2038 LX1970 Data Sheet Exhibit
EX2037 DigiKey Catalog Exhibit
Patent Owner Response RESPONSE
EX2030 Stevenson Declaration Exhibit
EX2035 US7270461 Exhibit
ORDER Granting Patent Owner’s Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Aidan M. Brewster 37 C.F.R. § 42.10 ORDER
Nintendo America's Power of Attorney Adding New Back Up Counsel NOTICE
Petitioners' Updated Mandatory Notice Regarding Back Up Counsel NOTICE
Nintendo's Power of Attorney Adding New Back Up Counsel NOTICE
Patent Owner's PHV Motion of Aidan M. Brewster MOTION
EX2026 - Brewster PHV Declaration Exhibit
Patent Owner's Updated POA NOTICE
Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE
Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition NOTICE
ORDER Granting Petitioner’s Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Patrick W. Lauppe 37 C.F.R. § 42.10 ORDER
ORDER Conditionally Granting Petitioner’s Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Stephen Smith 37 C.F.R. § 42.10 ORDER
Biography of Stephen Smith Exhibit
Biography of Patrick W. Lauppe Exhibit
Declaration of Stephen Smith ISO Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission Exhibit
Petitioner's Unopposed Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission for Stephen Smith MOTION
Petitioner's Unopposed Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission for Patrick W. Lauppe MOTION
Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
ORDER Granting Petitioner’s Unopposed Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Mark. R. Weinstein and Dena Chen ORDER
Declaration of Patrick W. Lauppe Exhibit
Notice of Joint Stipulation to Modify Due Dates 1-3 NOTICE
Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioner's Evidence OTHER
Petitioners' Unopposed of Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission for Mark R. Weinstein MOTION
Biography of Mark R. Weinstein Exhibit
Declaration of Dena Chen ISO Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission Exhibit
Petitioners' Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
Declaration of Mark R. Weinstein ISO Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission Exhibit
Biography of Dena Chen Exhibit
Petitioners' Unopposed Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission for Dena Chen MOTION
Institution Decision: Grant DECISION
Order: Other ORDER
Patent Owners Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE
EX2025 - Control No. 90019119 Information Disclosure Statement (July 19, 2023) Exhibit
EX2009 - MSFT Computer Dictionary Exhibit
EX2023 - IPR2020-01337 Institution Decision Exhibit
EX2002 - 818-cv-01571 Claim Construction Order Exhibit
EX2011 - IPR2018–01262 Petition Exhibit
EX2014 - IPR2020-00043 Petition Exhibit
EX2008 - IEEE Dictionary Exhibit
EX2005 - Television Engineering Handbook Exhibit
Patent Owner Preliminary Response POPR
EX2021 - IPR2020-01337 Petition Exhibit
EX2001 - 217-cv-00715 Claim Construction Order Exhibit
EX2007 - RCA Television Guide 2004 Exhibit
EX2006 - RCA Television Guide 2001 Exhibit
EX2015 - IPR2020-00043 POPR Exhibit
EX2004 - Grob Exhibit
EX2019 - IPR2020-01283 POPR Exhibit
EX2010 - '722 Patent File History Excerpt Exhibit
EX2020 - IPR2020-01283 Institution Decision Exhibit
EX2024 - Control No. 90019119 Office Action (June 2, 2023) Exhibit
EX2018 - IPR2020-01283 Petition Exhibit
EX2012 - IPR2018–01262 POPR Exhibit
EX2013 - IPR2018–01262 Institution Decision Exhibit
EX2017 - IPR2020-00043 Rehearing Decision Exhibit
EX2016 - IPR2020-00043 Institution Decision Exhibit
EX2003 - 818-cv-01571 Order re Supp'l Claim Construction Exhibit
EX2022 - IPR2020-01337 POPR Exhibit
Notice: Notice filing date accorded NOTICE
Patent Owner's Power of Attorney NOTICE
Patent Owner's Mandatory Notices NOTICE
Proof of Service of Summons dated 03/30/2022, Case 2:22-cv-00386 (WD Wash) Exhibit
Part 1 - Declaration of Ingrid Hsieh-Yee, Ph.D. Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 7,110,062 B1 to Whitted filed April 26, 1999 Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 4,769,708 to Stoughton filed Apr. 23, 1987 Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 6,798,395 to Yamauchi filed June 19, 2000 Exhibit
Declaration of R. Jacob Baker Exhibit
Excerpts from Nichols, Mathematics Dictionary and Handbook (1993) Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 5,825,408 to Yuyama filed January 11, 1996 Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 3,983,575 to Nagai, et al. filed May 12, 1975 Exhibit
Gregory, Full Complex Modulation Using etc., Applied Optics, (1992) Exhibit
Certified Translation of Shimomura Exhibit
Claim construction order entered on 11/26 /2019 Case 8:18-cv-01571 (CD Cal) Exhibit
Order staying proceedings entered on 01/31/2023, Case 2:22-cv-00386 (WD Wa) Exhibit
U.S. Pat Appl Pub. No. 2002/0167637 A1 filed February 21, 2002 Exhibit
Req Ex Parte Reexam of U.S. Patent No. 8,223,117 B1 Exhibit
Excerpts from Fink, Television Engineering Handbook (1957) Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 7,928,955 B1 to Bell filed March 13, 2000 Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 3,096,399 to Thomas filed December 30, 1960 Exhibit
Office Action Summary and Detailed Action from ’117 Patent Exhibit
Japanese Patent Application Publication No. H6[1994]-308891 to Yoko Shimomu Exhibit
Gildo Cecchin, One Knob Picture Control, IEEE (Aug. 1974) Exhibit
Kim, et al., An Image Interpolator etc., IEEE, (May 2001) Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 8,223,117 B2 to Ferguson filed 12/17/2008 Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 4,511,921 to Harlan filed June 16, 1982 Exhibit
Claim construction order entered on 1/7/2019, Case 2:17-cv-00715 (ED Tex) Exhibit
Notice : Power of Attorney - Nintendo Co., Ltd. NOTICE
Order Granting Req for Ex Parte Reexam Patent No. 8,223,117 B1 Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 6,947,017 B1 to Gettemy filed August 29, 2001 Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 6,207,943 B1 to Smelker filed October 30, 1998 Exhibit
Expert Report of Balakrishnan dated 1/25/2023 - Case 2:22-cv-00386 (WD Wash Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 3,813,686 to Mierzwinski filed April 13, 1973 Exhibit
Excerpts from Gary Rosenzweig, Using Macromedia Director 8 (2000) Exhibit
U.S. Patent No. 6,618,042 B1 to Powell filed October 28, 1999 Exhibit
Part 2 - Declaration of Ingrid Hsieh-Yee, Ph.D. Exhibit
Excerpts from Philip Kerman, ActionScripting in FLASH (2001) Exhibit
Petition : as filed PETITION
Claim construction order entered on 12/23/2019, Case 8:18-cv-01571 (CD Cal) Exhibit
Notice : Power of Attorney - Nintendo of America Inc. NOTICE
Part 3 - Declaration of Ingrid Hsieh-Yee, Ph.D. Exhibit
Download Proceeding Documents
Case IPR2023-00778 • 123 documents
Preparing ZIP Archive
Email verified! Bundling proceeding documents from USPTO. Your download will start automatically in a few seconds...