Bayer CropScience LP et al. vs. Corteva Agriscience LLC
Explore the PTAB proceeding IPR2023-01036 filed by Bayer CropScience LP et al. on 2023-06-15. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.
Proceeding Overview
Proceeding Number
IPR2023-01036
Filing Date
2023-06-15
Accorded Filing Date
2023-06-15
Institution Decision Date
2023-12-19
Last Modified Date
2025-02-18
Proceeding Type
IPR
Termination Date
2024-12-17
Trial Status
Final Written Decision - Appealed
Parties & Counsel
Petitioner
Bayer CropScience LP et al.
Represented By
Grossman, Dovet alPatent Owner / Respondent
Corteva Agriscience LLC
Represented By
DeRoo, Pieret alTribunal & Venue
Tribunal
Patent Trial and Appeal Board (USPTO)
Technology Center
TC 1600 - Biotechnology & Organic Chemistry
Patent Information
Address and Attorney/Agent Information
Power of Attorney & Correspondence
Attorney / Agent Information
| Reg # | Name | Phone |
|---|---|---|
| 28165 | Charles Lipsey | 571-203-2755 |
| 30413 | John Paul | 202-408-4109 |
| 30415 | Richard Racine | 202-408-4038 |
| 31744 | Richard Burgujian | 571-203-2790 |
| 32120 | Barbara Mccurdy | 202-408-4000 X4047 |
| 32409 | Bryan Diner | 202-408-4000 |
| 32824 | John Jakes | 202-408-4000 |
| 33234 | Michael Flibbert | 202-408-4000 |
| 33751 | Gerson Panitch | 202-408-4080 |
| 33971 | James Monroe | 202-408-4159 |
| 34872 | Leslie Mcdonell | 617-646-1650 |
| 36116 | Kathleen Daley | 202-408-4098 |
| 36532 | C Gramenopoulos | 202-408-4000 |
| 36743 | Jeffrey Berkowitz | 202-203-2710 |
| 37110 | Virginia Carron | 404-653-6452 |
| 38092 | Lawrence Burwell | 571-203-2721 |
| 38637 | William Trousdell | 703-966-3932 |
| 38742 | Anthony Gutowski | 571-203-2774 |
| 40132 | Erik Puknys | 650-849-6600 |
| 40524 | Michele Bosch | 202-408-4000 |
| 41034 | Steven Gelman | 202-408-4000 |
| 41469 | Mark Sweet | 202-408-4162 |
| 41475 | Eric Raciti | 617-646-1675 |
| 41538 | Timothy May | 202-408-4447 |
| 41545 | Mary Till | 202-408-4000 |
| 41705 | Frank Decosta Iii | 202-408-4012 |
| 41765 | Eric Fues | 202-408-4000 |
| 41893 | Houtan Khalili-Esfahani | 202-408-4106 |
| 41944 | Esther Lim | 202-408-4121 |
| 43662 | Anthony Hartmann | 202-408-4275 |
| 43916 | Parmanand Sharma | 202-408-4000 |
| 45284 | Louis Troilo | 202-408-6020 |
| 45777 | Darren Jiron | 571-203-2729 |
| 45958 | Anthony Tridico | 202-408-4173 |
| 46539 | James Barney | 202-408-4412 |
| 46693 | Mark Feldstein | 202-408-4092 |
| 46814 | D Kacedon | 202-408-4301 |
| 46859 | Lionel Lavenue | 571-203-2750 |
| 48108 | Naoki Yoshida | 202-408-4000 |
| 48275 | John Williamson | 202-408-4000 |
| 48564 | Adriana Burgy | 202-408-4345 |
| 50785 | Aaron Parker | 202-408-4387 |
| 52070 | Elizabeth Niemeyer | 202-408-4000 |
| 52259 | Charles Suh | 571-203-2700 |
| 52412 | Ningling Wang | 202-408-4218 |
| 53232 | Anthony Lombardi | 571-203-2779 |
| 54386 | William Raich | 202-408-4219 |
| 54464 | Jason Stach | 404-653-6428 |
| 54533 | M Weingarten | 404-653-6457 |
| 55190 | Mareesa Frederick | 202-408-4103 |
| 55413 | Gary Ma | 886-227-127001 |
| 55873 | Rajeev Gupta | 202--40-4352 |
| 55940 | John Mulcahy | 571-203-2700 |
| 56170 | Aaron Capron | 650-849-6680 |
| 56939 | Timothy Mcanulty | 202-408-4348 |
| 57292 | Li Feng | 202-408-4000 |
| 57540 | Erika Arner | 571-203-2754 |
| 58221 | Jacob Schroeder | 650-849-6765 |
| 58275 | Jeffrey Freeman | 404-653-6430 |
| 58415 | Elizabeth Ferrill | 202-404-4445 |
| 59369 | Joshua Goldberg | 202-408-6092 |
| 59387 | Amanda Murphy | 202-408-4000 |
| 59461 | Abhay Watwe | 571-203-2716 |
| 59613 | John Livingstone | 404-653-6400 |
| 59639 | Daniel Cooley | 571-203-2778 |
| 59665 | Jason Romrell | 202-408-4349 |
| 60974 | Erin Sommers | 202-408-4000 |
| 61119 | Aidan Skoyles | 202-408-4417 |
| 61180 | Michael Young | 571-203-2788 |
| 61329 | Qingyu Yin | 202-408-4213 |
| 61581 | Jana Harris | 617-871-8000 |
| 61769 | Elliot Cook | 571-203-2738 |
| 62019 | Ming-Tao Yang | 650-849-6783 |
| 62180 | Justin Hasford | 202-408-4000 |
| 62521 | Mark Hanson | 857-330-9992 |
| 62694 | James Bell | 331-449-48630 |
| 62781 | Daniel Tucker | 571-203-2793 |
| 63553 | Daniel Chung | 202-408-4000 |
| 63681 | Arpita Bhattacharyya | 650-849-6650 |
| 63684 | Biju Chandran | 202-808-3550 |
| 63906 | Nishla Keiser | 617-646-1630 |
| 64621 | Aya Suzuki | 202-408-4277 |
| 65125 | Joseph Long | 202-408-4000 |
| 65162 | Jeffrey Jacobstein | 617-646-1664 |
| 65229 | Jeffrey Totten | 202-408-4000 |
| 65418 | Yanbin Xu | 202-408-6011 |
| 65499 | Yelena Morozova | +44-020-7864 2800 |
| 65506 | Kevin Rodkey | 404-653-6484 |
| 66116 | David Mroz | 202-408-4022 |
| 66153 | Jeffrey Smyth | 650-849-6600 |
| 66219 | Sarah Rodriguez | 442-078-642800 |
| 66599 | Alexander Boyer | 484-832-5183 |
| 66946 | Andrea Mills | 512-293-9416 |
| 67191 | Ryan O'Quinn | 571-203-2426 |
| 68332 | Cora Holt | -- |
| 68664 | Christopher Johns | 202-408-4155 |
| 69029 | Christopher Blackford | 202-408-4000 |
| 69325 | Benjamin Saidman | 404-653-6510 |
| 69340 | Pier Deroo | 202-408-4000 |
| 69397 | Yi Yu | 571-203-2479 |
| 69560 | Kara Specht | 678-361-5914 |
| 69633 | Yan Hankin | 401-556-6797 |
| 69674 | Mingji Jin | 202-408-6020 |
| 69800 | Audrey Chang | 510-845-7169 |
| 70110 | Kai Rajan | 202-408-4307 |
| 70657 | Kelly Horn | -- |
| 70779 | Yuefei Ma | 571-203-2702 |
| 70914 | Jinwoo Kim | 650-849-6600 |
| 70927 | Sonja Sahlsten | 202-408-4329 |
| 71228 | Sara Leiman | 617-495-0532 |
| 71337 | Adam Boger | 216-255-4865 |
| 71393 | Daniel Roland | 202-598-7270 |
| 71505 | Alissa Lipton | 617-646-1600 |
| 71900 | Nicholas Cerulli | 202-480-4248 |
| 71923 | Yieyie Yang | 617-416-7098 |
| 71998 | Jennifer Roscetti | 202-408-4150 |
| 72334 | Matthew Hlinka | 202-408-4333 |
| 72482 | Yinan Liu | 857-272-6038 |
| 72627 | Ryan Davies | 903-935-2912 |
| 72693 | Daniel Klodowski | 202-408-4216 |
| 74083 | Kassandra Officer | 202-408-4270 |
| 74123 | Forrest Jones | 202-408-4019 |
| 74264 | Tyler Akagi | 202-408-4385 |
| 74279 | Matthew Karas | 404-653-6439 |
| 74972 | Henry Shikani | 202-408-4330 |
| 75004 | Jeanette Roorda | 202-408-4008 |
| 75006 | Bradford Schulz | 571-203-2739 |
| 75096 | Cory Bell | 617-646-1641 |
| 75786 | Robert High Iii | 404-653-6564 |
| 76015 | Laura Smith | 617-646-1629 |
| 76098 | Umber Aggarwal | 202-408-4154 |
| 76224 | Jency Mathew | 571-203-2700 |
| 76631 | Marta Daneshvar | 650-849-6670 |
| 77044 | Benjamin Hemmelgarn | 202-408-4026 |
| 77225 | James Masters | 202-408-4127 |
| 77531 | Paul Browning | 202-408-4134 |
| 77898 | Christopher Anderson | 571-203-2765 |
| 77963 | Anthony Berlenbach | 202-408-4135 |
| 78004 | Drew Christie | 571-203-2732 |
| 78038 | Daniel Jordan | 571-203-2471 |
| 78062 | Megan Meyers | 404-653-6565 |
| 78149 | Min Yang | 202-408-4163 |
| 78158 | Matthew Everhart | 202-408-4278 |
| 78214 | Victor Palace | 303-704-3814 |
| 78238 | Michael Mclaughlin | 202-408-4220 |
| 78309 | Antoinette Nibbs | 617-646-1649 |
| 78500 | Jameson Gardner | 571-203-2425 |
| 78501 | Alissa Green | 202-408-4305 |
| 78730 | Kaitlyn Pehrson | 202-573-1738 |
| 78750 | Colin Kreutzer | 202-408-4217 |
| 78809 | Xirui Zhang | 617-646-1626 |
| 78843 | Nicholas Eitsert | 202-731-4524 |
| 78874 | William Neer | 636-375-6437 |
| 78998 | Yoonhee Kim | 202-408-4214 |
| 79011 | Alexander Newkirk | 919-271-7672 |
| 79064 | Luke Macdonald | 571-203-2742 |
| 79097 | David Lebby Jr. | 202-768-5651 |
| 79112 | Andrew Schneider | 202-709-1684 |
| 79185 | Candace Walther | 414-698-3495 |
| 79267 | Abhinav Garg | 585-752-9243 |
| 79284 | Deanna Smiley | 571-203-2717 |
| 79293 | Shannon Yi | 202-408-4310 |
| 79393 | Christopher Kim | 267-218-6821 |
| 79544 | Christopher Howes | 202-408-4356 |
| 79595 | Guanshi Li | 617-646-1653 |
| 79634 | Connor Mcgregor | 757-645-6437 |
| 79767 | Taylor Stark | 571-203-2719 |
| 79821 | Emma Ng | 303-518-2957 |
| 79853 | Jordan Gringauz | 954-375-0368 |
| 79876 | Jenna Logsdon | 813-974-0994 |
| 79954 | Soniya Shah | 716-796-5587 |
| 800050 | Yi Yang | 857-328-7055 |
| 800103 | Tobias Koengeter | 857-361-9147 |
| 80028 | Annmarie Dressler | 571-449-1652 |
| 80129 | Dara Emami | 757-871-3645 |
| 80268 | Robert Wright | 404-653-6555 |
| 80379 | Taryn Willett | 513-520-4121 |
| 80472 | Angeline Premraj | 202-408-4174 |
| 80559 | Carlos Duarte Guevara | 202-408-6013 |
| 80697 | Alexandra Hoyt | 202-412-6204 |
| 80702 | Audrey Parker | 202-408-4000 |
| 80837 | Kathleen Galleher | 301-807-9029 |
| 80845 | Joseph Myles | 202-408-4372 |
| 80990 | Benjamin Levitas | 202-408-4000 |
| 81020 | Stephanie Ham | 703-389-1274 |
| 81134 | Daniel Rivalti | 202-251-1052 |
| 81220 | Milan Feliciello | 202-408-4317 |
| 81346 | Bushra Haque | 703-965-1450 |
| 81437 | Shawn Chang | 404-653-6455 |
| 81559 | Mark Lampert | 202-408-4000 |
| 81568 | Chen Zang | 202-408-4000 |
| 81666 | Laura Lyons | 617-646-1632 |
| 81671 | Christian Sanders | 240-507-4547 |
| 81723 | Lu Liu | 650-512-3540 |
| 81757 | Laura Brashear | 571-203-2735 |
| 81865 | Shannon Patrick | 770-366-9373 |
| 81921 | Leith Shafi | 202-408-4413 |
| 81980 | Caitlin Coverstone | 202-408-4129 |
| 82089 | Heather Ren | 202-408-4024 |
| 82107 | Ilana Kelsey | 617-530-0261 |
| 82361 | Rebecca Richardson | 202-408-4364 |
| 82462 | Samir Ismail | 202-408-4015 |
| 82475 | Madeline Herman | 617-686-7206 |
| 82481 | Ryan Ponzi | 857-278-5398 |
| 82489 | Comfort Adeyemi | 267-984-2162 |
| 82508 | Sarah Slone | 202-408-4252 |
| 82581 | Liam Gaynor | 617-571-5003 |
| 82922 | Alex Wang | 202-408-4253 |
| 83158 | Emma Capitanelli | 202-699-2956 |
| 83298 | Richmond Van Winter | 202-408-4309 |
| 83310 | Lin Ao | 617-548-8543 |
| 83353 | Deena Lanier | 202-408-4115 |
| L0906 | Karthik Kumar | 202-408-4433 |
| L1076 | Chiaki Fujiwara | 202-408-4163 |
| L1374 | Yicong Du | 202-408-4015 |
Proceeding Documents
190Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal NOTICE
Exhibit 3006 Exhibit
CONDUCT OF THE PROCEEDING 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.5, 42.54, 42.56 ORDER
PUBLIC VERSION- JUDGMENT Final Written Decision Determining All Challenged Claims Unpatentable 35 U.S.C. § 318(a) Granting Patent Owner’s Motions to Seal (Papers 27, 32, 37) 37 C.F.R. § 42.14 (Originally entered on 12/17/2024) NOTICE
Ex. 3005 Exhibit
EX1070 2024.07.01 Hausinger Reply Declaration (Public Redacted) Exhibit
Petitioners' Reply to Patent Owner's Response (Public Redacted) OTHER
Other: Hearing transcript OTHER
Patent Owner's Fourth Unopposed Motion to Seal MOTION
Corteva's Trial Demonstratives Exhibit
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
Petitioners' Demonstrative Exhibits (Public Redacted) OTHER
Order: Setting Oral Argument 37 C.F.R. sec. 42.70 ORDER
Petitioners' Objections to Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List OTHER
(PUBLIC) Deposition Transcript of Dr. Hausinger (Aug. 1, 2024) Exhibit
Patent Owner's Sur-Reply OTHER
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
Patent Owner's Third Unopposed Motion to Seal MOTION
Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument MOTION
Petitioners' Request for Oral Argument MOTION
Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Robert P. Hausinger NOTICE
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioners' Evidence OTHER
Patent Owner's Second Unopposed Motion to Seal MOTION
EX1080 Coffa 2005 Exhibit
EX1072 Bollinger Deposition Transcript Exhibit
EX1082 Baerga-Ortiz 2006 Exhibit
EX1081 Ijima 2005 Exhibit
EX1073 Hausinger Curriculum Vitae Exhibit
EX1076 IUBMB Exhibit
EX1077 UniProt P10088 Exhibit
EX1075 UniProt Website Exhibit
EX1074 Bairoch 1999 Exhibit
EX1078 Nakajima 1999 Exhibit
EX1084 Excerpt Exhibit
EX1079 Valmsen 2004 Exhibit
EX1083 Weiss 2016 Exhibit
Petitioners' Notice of Deposition of J. Martin Bollinger, Jr., Ph.D. NOTICE
Order: AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER ORDER
Petitioners' Objections to Patent Owner's Evidence Filed and Served with Patent Owner's Response OTHER
Dayhoff 1978 Exhibit
Rost 1999 Exhibit
Minarik 2002 Exhibit
Wilson 2000 Exhibit
Tipton 2000 Exhibit
Wedege 1986 Exhibit
Hausinger 1983 Exhibit
Altschul 1997 Exhibit
Llewellyn and Last 1996 Exhibit
Paine 2005 Exhibit
Nakajima 1998 Exhibit
Schleinitz excerpt Exhibit
Chaparro-Riggers 2007 Exhibit
desJardins 1997 Exhibit
MH043108 Exhibit
Galperin 1998 Exhibit
Herbicide Handbook 2002 Exhibit
Ng and Henikoff 2003 Exhibit
Rost 2002 Exhibit
Multiple Sequence Alignment FT Exhibit
MH043109 Exhibit
Robinson 2015 Exhibit
Todd 2001 Exhibit
Devos 2000 Exhibit
Minshull 2005 Exhibit
Cox 2004 Exhibit
Hausinger Depo Transcript Exhibit
Tian 2003 Exhibit
US8343747 Exhibit
Llewelyn 1992 Exhibit
Chica 2005 Exhibit
Patent Owner's Response RESPONSE
Merriam-Webster responsible Exhibit
Chung and Subbiah 1996 Exhibit
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
Price and Arkin 2017 Exhibit
MH043110 Exhibit
Larue 2023 Exhibit
Last and Llewellyn 1999 Exhibit
Bollinger Declaration Exhibit
Müller and Vingron 2000 Exhibit
Dym and Eisenberg 2001 Exhibit
Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Robert P. Hausinger NOTICE
Institution decision and grant of joinder, IPR2024-00179 NOTICE
Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE
Notice of Stipulation to Modify Trial Due Date 1 NOTICE
Notice of Stipulation to Modify Trial Dates 1-3 NOTICE
(PUBLIC) CORRECTED Excerpted Counterclaims to 2d Am Compl_Part 2 of 4 Exhibit
(PUBLIC) CORRECTED Excerpted Counterclaims to 2d Am Compl_Part 3 of 4 Exhibit
(PUBLIC) CORRECTED Excerpted Counterclaims to 2d Am Compl_Part 1 of 4 Exhibit
(PUBLIC) CORRECTED Excerpted Counterclaims to 2d Am Compl_Part 4 of 4 Exhibit
ORDER Conditionally Granting Patent Owner’s Unopposed Motion to Seal and Enter Agreed-To Protective Order 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.5, 42.14, 42.54 ORDER
Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Exhibit List OTHER
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioners' Evidence OTHER
Order: SCHEDULING ORDER ORDER
Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314 DECISION
Exhibit 3003 Exhibit
Exhibit 3004 Exhibit
Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE
Exhibit 3002 Exhibit
Patent Owner's Sur-Reply OTHER
Petitioners' Authorized Reply to Patent Owner's Preliminary Response OTHER
Exhibit 3001 Exhibit
(PUBLIC) Excerpted Counterclaims to 2d Am Compl_Part 1 of 4 Exhibit
(PUBLIC) Excerpted Counterclaims to 2d Am Compl_Part 2 of 4 Exhibit
Fukumori 1993 Exhibit
(PUBLIC) Excerpted Counterclaims to 2d Am Compl_Part 3 of 4 Exhibit
Patent Owner's Preliminary Response POPR
(PUBLIC) Excerpted Counterclaims to 2d Am Compl_Part 4 of 4 Exhibit
Patent Owner's Unopposed Motion to Seal and Enter Agreed-To Protective Order MOTION
GenBank Accession No. MH043115 Exhibit
GenBank Accession No. MH043114 Exhibit
GenBank Accession No. MH043112 Exhibit
Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE
Patent Owner's Mandatory Notices NOTICE
Notice: Notice filing date accorded NOTICE
2023.06.14 Julian Declaration Exhibit
Bayley 1992 Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 5 of 9) Exhibit
Vedler 2004 Exhibit
US6153401 (Streber) Exhibit
Krausz 1993 Exhibit
Petition : as filed PETITION
Larue 2019 Exhibit
Statistics Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 2 of 9) Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 6 of 9) Exhibit
Saari 1998 Exhibit
Nickel 1997 Exhibit
US10947555 Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 9 of 9) Exhibit
Muller 2006 Exhibit
Hotopp 2002 Exhibit
Lyon 1989 Exhibit
Schleinitz EMBL RdpA AF516751 ('733 File History) Exhibit
WO2005107437 (Corteva '437) Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 8 of 9) Exhibit
US11587893 & File History Certified (Part 2 of 2) Exhibit
WorldCat Entry Exhibit
Schleinitz EMBL RdpA AF516752 ('733 File History) Exhibit
Notice : Power of Attorney NOTICE
Hee 1981 (Part 1 of 2) Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 4 of 9) Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 1 of 9) Exhibit
2023.06.09 Joint Claim Construction Chart Exhibit
WorldCat Search Exhibit
Saari 1998 Exhibit
Saari 1999 Exhibit
Hotopp 2001 Exhibit
2023.06.14 Hausinger Declaration Exhibit
US12951813 & File History Exhibit
US17143824 & File History (Part 2 of 2) Exhibit
Hogan 2000 Exhibit
Lyon 1993 Exhibit
Rao 2000 Exhibit
Westendorf 2002 Exhibit
US11149283 Exhibit
FirstSearch Entry Exhibit
US11299745 Exhibit
Perkins 1987 Exhibit
Elkins 2002 Exhibit
Fukumori & Hausinger 1993 Exhibit
US11587893 & File History Certified (Part 1 of 2) Exhibit
Kohler NCBI RdpA AJ628859 ('733 File History) Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 7 of 9) Exhibit
US17175966 Certified (COR-AAD1-00005481) Exhibit
US17403476 Certified (COR-AAD1-00005063) Exhibit
Hee 1981 (Part 2 of 2) Exhibit
MSU Library Website Exhibit
2023.04.25 [66] PUBLIC VERSION of Stipulation Exhibit
US20160108422 (Bayer '422) Exhibit
US20030041357 (Jepson) Exhibit
Chekan 2019 Suppl Info Exhibit
Vedler NCBI TfdA AAS549436.1 (COR-AAD1-00003374) Exhibit
US17143824 & File History (Part 1 of 2) Exhibit
Streber 1989 Exhibit
Schleinitz 2004 Exhibit
Hausinger Curriculum Vitae Exhibit
US14820893 & File History Exhibit
US60567052 Exhibit
Chekan 2019 Exhibit
Cutler 1999 Exhibit
US15288406 & File History Certified (COR-AAD1-00000001) (Part 3 of 9) Exhibit
Kohler 1999 Exhibit
Oxtoby 1990 Exhibit
2023.04.28 [68, 68-1] PUBLIC VERSION of Amended Complaint Exhibit
Streber 1987 Exhibit
Kohler NCBI RdpA Q8KSC8 (COR-AAD1-00003391) Exhibit
Muller 2001 Exhibit
Hausinger 2004 Exhibit
Westendorf 2003 Exhibit
Download Proceeding Documents
Case IPR2023-01036 • 190 documents
Preparing ZIP Archive
Email verified! Bundling proceeding documents from USPTO. Your download will start automatically in a few seconds...