Home › PTAB Cases › IPR2023-01369

Align Technology, Inc. vs. Dental Monitoring SAS

Explore the PTAB proceeding IPR2023-01369 filed by Align Technology, Inc. on 2023-08-31. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Proceeding Overview

Proceeding Number

IPR2023-01369

Filing Date

2023-08-31

Accorded Filing Date

2023-08-31

Institution Decision Date

2024-03-05

Last Modified Date

2026-10-07

Proceeding Type

IPR

Termination Date

2025-03-03

Trial Status

Final Written Decision

Parties & Counsel

Petitioner

Align Technology, Inc.

Represented By

Rosato, Michaelet al

Patent Owner / Respondent

Dental Monitoring SAS

Represented By

Sandonato, Michaelet al

Tribunal & Venue

Tribunal

Patent Trial and Appeal Board (USPTO)

Technology Center

TC 2600 - Communications

Patent Information

1 Patent Involved

Respondent Application Number 16031201

Respondent Patent Number 10755409

External Links

Espacenet

Google Patents

Respondent Inventor Philippe SALAH et al

Respondent Tech Center TC 2600 - Communications

Address and Attorney/Agent Information

6 Registered Practitioners

Power of Attorney & Correspondence

Firm / Entity Name Ronald M. Kachmarik - Cooper Legal Group LLC

Customer Number 108676

Address 1388 Ridge Road, Unit 1, Hinckley, OH, 44233, UNITED STATES

Attorney / Agent Information

Reg #	Name	Phone
34512	Ronald Kachmarik	216-654-0090
44629	William Cooper	216-654-0090
47965	David Stein	703-668-8000
60870	Daniel Tate	330-571-0999
61201	Marcus Fischer	216-654-0090
65848	Ali Assar	216-654-0090

Proceeding Documents

141

Patent Owner's Third Updated Mandatory Notice NOTICE

2026-10-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Patent Owner's Power of Attorney NOTICE

2026-10-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Notice of Appearance of Backup Counsel OTHER

2026-10-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Notice of Appearance of Lead Counsel OTHER

2026-10-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

ORDER Conditionally Granting Patent Owner’s Motion to Withdraw and Substitute Counsel ORDER

2026-10-07 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Patent Owner’s Unopposed Motion for Withdrawal of Charlotte Jacobsen, Joshua Krevitt, Jaysen S. Chung, and Andrew Blythe as Lead and Back-Up Counsel for Patent Owner MOTION

2026-09-25 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Other: Fed Circuit mandate OTHER

2026-09-16 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Other: other court decision OTHER

2026-09-16 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Patent Owner's Notice of Appeal NOTICE

2025-05-05 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Notice of Appearance of Additional Backup Counsel NOTICE

2025-05-05 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Notice of Appearance of Additional Backup Counsel NOTICE

2025-05-05 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Patent Owner's Second Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE

2025-05-02 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Final Written Decision: original FINAL

2025-03-03 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Other: Hearing transcript OTHER

2025-01-15 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

1051

Petitioner's Demonstratives Exhibit

2024-11-27 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE

2024-11-27 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

2055

Patent Owner’s Demonstratives Exhibit

2024-11-27 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

PATENT OWNER DENTAL MONITORING SAS'S UPDATED EXHIBIT LIST NOTICE

2024-11-27 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION TO EXCLUDE REPLY

2024-11-26 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

None

PATENT OWNER’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION TO EXCLUDE REPLY

2024-11-26 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

LEAP Practitioner Request and Verification Form (Patent Owner) NOTICE

2024-11-25 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE

2024-11-19 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude OPPOSITION

2024-11-19 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1029

Second Foroosh Declaration Exhibit

2024-11-19 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S MOTION TO EXCLUDE MOTION

2024-11-12 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Order: Setting Oral Argument - 37 CFR 42.70 ORDER

2024-10-24 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

PATENT OWNER’S REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT MOTION

2024-10-22 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Petitioner's Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE

2024-10-22 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument OTHER

2024-10-22 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

2053

Deposition Transcript of Dr. Maureen Valley Exhibit

2024-10-01 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S SUR-REPLY OTHER

2024-10-01 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2054

Second Deposition of Dr. Hasan Foroosh Exhibit

2024-10-01 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Petitioner's Identification of POR Arguments OTHER

2024-09-16 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S LISTING OF NEW ARGUMENTS IN PETITIONER’S REPLY OTHER

2024-09-09 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF DR. HASSAN FOROOSH NOTICE

2024-09-04 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF DR. MAUREEN VALLEY NOTICE

2024-09-03 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S SECOND OBJECTIONS TO EVIDENCE OTHER

2024-08-27 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

1036

Curriculum Vitae of Maureen Valley, D.M.D., M.P.H., M.S. Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1033

Rajkomar et al., “High-Throughput Classification of Radiographs Using Deep Convolutional Neural Networks,” J. Digital Imaging, 30, 95-101 (Feb. 2017) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1041

Howard et al., “MobileNets: Efficient Convolutional Neural Networks for Mobile Vision Applications,” arXiv.org (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1704.04861v1) (Apr. 17, 2017) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1050

Order Granting Final Judgment Pursuant to Joint Stipulation, Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc., Case No. 3-22-cv-07335 (N.D. Cal., Aug. 8, 2024) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1040

Wu et al., “Quantized Convolutional Neural Networks for Mobile Devices,” arXiv.org (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1512.06473v3) (May 16, 2016) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Response REPLYTOOPP

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1031

Second Declaration of Nathaniel E. Frank-Wright Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1042

Ross Girshick, “Fast R-CNN,” arXiv.org (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1504.08083v2) (Sep. 27, 2015) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1049

Deposition Transcript of Dr. Hassan Foroosh (with errata) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1030

Declaration of Nathaniel E. Frank-Wright Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1038

Deposition Transcript of Dr. Budi Kusnoto (Aug. 9, 2024) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1039

Liu et al., “Sparse Convolutional Neural Networks,” 2015 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR) (2015) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1048

Reply Declaration of Dr. Hassan Foroosh Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1043

Dong-Hyun Lee, “Pseudo-Label: The Simple and Efficient Semi-Supervised Learning Method for Deep Neural Networks,” ResearchGate Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1047

Schnitman et al., “Inducing Semantic Segmentation from an Example,” Computer Vision—ACCV 2006 (2006) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1044

Patrini et al., “Making Deep Neural Networks Robust to Label Noise: a Loss Correction Approach,” arXiv.org (https://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.03683v2) (Mar. 22, 2017) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1035

Declaration of Dr. Maureen Valley Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1046

“iPhone Xs and iPhone Xs Max Bring the Best and Biggest Displays to iPhone,” Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1037

Deposition Transcript of Dr. John Mongan (July 23, 2024) Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1045

“Apple Presents iPhone 4,” https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2010/06/07Apple-Presents-iPhone-4/ Exhibit

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Notice of Deposition of Dr. Kusnoto NOTICE

2024-07-29 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Notice of Deposition of Dr. Mongan NOTICE

2024-07-11 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Petitioner's Second Objections to Evidence OTHER

2024-06-04 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

2042

S. Xie & Z. Tu, Holistically-Nested Edge Detection Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2029

Updated Curriculum Vitae of John T. Mongan, M.D., Ph.D. Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2043

M. Owen, How iPhone Speeds Have Grown in the Last 5 Years, Apple Insider Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2040

S. Samawi, Clinical Digital Photography in Orthodontics: Professional Photographic Records in Daily Practice Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S RESPONSE TO PETITION RESPONSE

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2036

Excerpts from Transcript of Deposition of Dr. Maureen A. Valley in IPR2019-00132 Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2045

B. Lang, NVIDIA’s Next-Gen Titan X Has 11 TFLOPS Performance, 12GB of Memory, and Costs 1 Arm and 1 Leg Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2030

Expert Declaration of Dr. Budi Kusnoto, D.D.S., M.S. Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2046

Ahmad, Digital Dental Photography, Part 2: Purposes and Uses Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2031

Curriculum Vitae of Budi Kusnoto, D.D.S., M.S. Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2044

Apple, iOS 11 is Available Tomorrow, Apple Newsroom Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2034

Institute of Medical Illustrators, IMI National Guidelines: Orthodontic Photography Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2020

The PASCAL VOC 2012 Segmentation dataset Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2033

American Board of Orthodontists, Ideal Photographs and Radiographs Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2041

O. Russakovsky et al. ImageNet Large Scale Visual Recognition Challenge Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2028

Expert Declaration of Dr. John T. Mongan, M.D., Ph.D. Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2035

Canon, Canon Dental Photography Guide Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2037

Excerpts from Declaration of Dr. Maureen A. Valley in Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc. Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2038

R. Kaplan, Standardization for Serial Intraoral Photography Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2039

J. Liu et al., Machine Learning in Orthodontics: Challenges and Perspectives Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2047

S. Finlay, Photographic Analysis and Diagnosis: Step One, 2(3) Inside Dentistry Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2032

2023 Economics of Orthodontics Analysis Reporting on 2022 Practice & Patient Statistics: Member Report Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2048

Deposition Transcript of Dr. Hassan Foroosh, Ph.D., in IPR2023-01269 Exhibit

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Deposition Notice of Dr. Hassan Foroosh NOTICE

2024-05-03 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S UPDATED MANDATORY NOTICES NOTICE

2024-04-24 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S UPDATED POWER OF ATTORNEY NOTICE

2024-04-24 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

Petitioner's Objections to Evidence OTHER

2024-03-19 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S OBJECTIONS TO EVIDENCE OTHER

2024-03-19 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

SCHEDULING ORDER ORDER

2024-03-05 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314 DECISION

2024-03-05 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Petitioner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE

2024-01-09 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

1028

Stipulation – Defendant Align Technology, Inc.’s Stipulation re Challenged Claims in IPR2023-01369 filed Jan. 8, 2024, Case 3:22-cv-07335-WHA Exhibit

2024-01-09 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

3001

Exhibit 3001 Exhibit

2024-01-05 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

2003

Curriculum Vitae of John T. Mongan, MD, PhD Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2008

Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc., Case No. 22-cv-07335, Dkt. No. 59, Order Denying Second Motion to Dismiss Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2011

Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc., Case No. 22-cv-07335, Dkt. No. 92, Order Re Updated Patent Showdown Deadlines Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2009

Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc., Case No. 22-cv-07335, Defendant’s Patent Local Rule 3-3 and 3-4 Initial Invalidity Contentions and Disclosures Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2006

Andri et al., YodaNN: An Architecture for Ultralow Power Binary-Weight CNN Acceleration Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2010

Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc., Case No. 22-cv-07335, Dkt. No. 86, Align’s Notice of Pending Inter Partes Review Petition Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2013

Docket Navigator Report on Time to Trial in cases before Judge Alsup Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2004

Redline of Carrier against the Carrier Provisional Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2012

Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc., Case No. 22-cv-07335, Dkt. No. 56, Patent Showdown Scheduling Order Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2007

Shrestha and Dang, Deep Learning-Based Real-Time Auto Classification of Smartphone Measured Bridge Vibration Data Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2005

GeForce GTX TITAN X Specifications Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

2002

Declaration of John Mongan Exhibit

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

PATENT OWNER’S PRELIMINARY RESPONSE POPR

2023-12-07 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

DECISION Granting Patent Owner’s Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Joshua A. Krevitt 37 C.F.R. § 42.10 (c) ORDER

2023-11-14 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Patent Owner's Motion for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Joshua Krevitt MOTION

2023-11-06 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWN

Download

2001

DECLARATION OF JOSHUA KREVITT IN SUPPORT OF PATENT OWNER'S MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE ADMISSION Exhibit

2023-11-06 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWN

Download

Notice : Patent Owner's Mandatory Notice NOTICE

2023-10-09 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWN

Download

Notice : Patent Owner's Power of Attorney NOTICE

2023-10-09 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWN

Download

Notice: Notice filing date accorded NOTICE

2023-09-07 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

1027