Apple Inc. vs. Masimo Corporation

Explore the PTAB proceeding IPR2024-00242 filed by Apple Inc. on 2023-12-12. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Proceeding Overview

Proceeding Number

IPR2024-00242

Filing Date

2023-12-12

Accorded Filing Date

2023-12-12

Institution Decision Date

2024-07-09

Last Modified Date

2024-08-20

Proceeding Type

IPR

Termination Date

2024-07-09

Trial Status

Institution Denied

Parties & Counsel

Petitioner

Apple Inc.

Represented By

Renner, W. Karlet al

Patent Owner / Respondent

Masimo Corporation

Represented By

Claassen, Brianet al

Tribunal & Venue

Tribunal

Patent Trial and Appeal Board (USPTO)

Technology Center

TC 3700 - Mechanical Engineering & Manufacturing

Patent Information

1 Patent Involved

Respondent Application Number 16791955

Respondent Patent Number 10687743

External Links

Espacenet

Google Patents

Respondent Inventor Ammar Al-Ali

Respondent Tech Center TC 3700 - Mechanical Engineering & Manufacturing

Address and Attorney/Agent Information

178 Registered Practitioners

Power of Attorney & Correspondence

Firm / Entity Name Knobbe, Martens, Olson & Bear, LLP - MASIMO CORPORATION (MASIMO)

Customer Number 64735

Address 2040 MAIN STREET, FOURTEENTH FLOOR, IRVINE, CA, 92614, UNITED STATES

Attorney / Agent Information

Reg #	Name	Phone
31291	Joseph Re	949-760-0404
31430	Craig Summers	949-760-0404
32297	Edward Schlatter	949-760-0404
34115	Daniel Altman	949-760-0404
34362	John King	949-760-0404
35556	Stephen Jensen	949-760-0404
36516	Michael Fuller	858-707-4000
37688	Steven Nataupsky	949-760-0404
37924	Raimond Salenieks	858-707-4000
39287	Joseph Mallon	858-707-4000
39901	Neil Bartfeld	858-707-4202
40574	Maria Anderson	206-405-2000
40664	Joseph Jennings	949-760-0404
41371	David Weiss	310-551-3450
41394	Adeel Akhtar	415-954-4114
42610	John Grover	949-760-0404
42856	Thomas Mcclenahan	949-297-7074
43622	Mark Gallagher	949-760-0404
43745	Sabing Lee	949-760-0404
43878	Joseph Reisman	858-707-4000
44087	Paul Conover	949-760-0404
44328	Melanie Seelig	206-405-2000
45664	Eric Furman	858-707-4000
46206	Mauricio Uribe	206-405-2000
46547	Matthew Bellinger	949-760-0404
47677	Bruce Itchkawitz	949-760-0404
48877	Curtis Huffmire	949-760-0404
51212	Andrew Douglas	949-760-0404
51240	Linda Liu	949-760-0404
51241	James Herkenhoff	6503282844
51754	Christy Green	949-760-0404
51922	Irfan Lateef	949-721-7672
52082	Perry Oldham	949-721-2961
53018	Gregory Hermanson	858-707-4000
53084	Mark Kachner	310-551-3450
53102	Benjamin Katzenellenbogen	(617) 499-6200
53317	Andrew Merickel	415-954-4114
53428	Yichuan Pan	858-707-4000
53658	Sheila Swaroop	949-760-0404
54198	Russell Jeide	949-760-0404
54511	Josue Villalta	949-760-0404
54618	Karen Lenker	949-760-0404
55030	Cheryl Burgess	949-721-2935
55036	Ted Cannon	949-760-0404
55310	Agnes Juang	949-760-0404
55634	Raymond Smith	949-760-0404
56553	Lauren Keller	949-721-6365
57046	Jarom Kesler	949-760-0404
57505	Michael Christensen	949-760-0404
57571	Maria Stout	858-707-4000
57871	Mark Marsden	858-707-4000
58474	Jared Bunker	949-760-0404
58621	Ryan Melnick	858-707-4000
58855	Andrew Kimmel	949-760-0404
59362	Lincoln Essig	202-640-6400
59406	David Trossen	415-954-4114
59856	Terry Tullis	949-760-0404
60295	Brenden Gingrich	858-707-4000
60659	Benjamin Everton	949-760-0404
60771	Ali Razai	949-760-0404
60934	Christopher Ross	949-760-0404
61224	Carol Pitzel Cruz	206-405-2000
61513	Colin Heideman	206-405-2000
61546	Theodore Papagiannis	949-760-0404
61557	Nicholas Zovko	949-760-0404
61569	Qian Dai	858-707-4000
61595	Susan Natland	949-760-0404
61749	Kimberly Miller	858-707-4000
61805	Jason Jardine	858-707-4000
62027	Aaron Davis	415-954-4114
62207	Benjamin Anger	858-707-4000
62280	Ian Gillies	858-707-4000
62676	Philip Nelson	949-760-0404
62933	Christie Matthaei	206-405-2000
63035	Kregg Koch	310-551-3450
63051	Brian Claassen	949-760-0404
63106	Chang Lim	949-760-0404
63160	Nathanael Luman	858-836-9000
63635	Alan Laquer	949-760-0404
63934	Jeffery Hallstrom	949-760-0404
64096	Joshua Stowell	949-760-9562
64420	Jason Swartz	609/734-6888
64970	Morgan Coates	949-760-0404
65026	Devanie Dufour	202-640-6400
65066	Scott Cromar	949-721-2812
65096	Jacob Peterson	206-274-6400
65157	Laura Hall	949-721-7686
65290	Sean Ambrosius	949-760-0404
65562	Derek Dailey	858-707-4000
65614	Shannon Lam	949-760-0404
65642	Andrea Cheek	202-640-6400
65994	Marko Zoretic	949-760-0404
66152	Lance Smemoe	949-760-0404
66226	Derek Bayles	949-760-0404
66385	Joan Chan	949-760-0404
66766	Andrew Lloyd	949-760-0404
67249	Kyu Min	415-954-4114
67720	Salima Merani	949-760-0404
67824	Hochan Song	949-760-0404
67884	Jonathan Bachand	202-640-6400
68005	Vikas Bhargava	949-760-0404
68069	Vladislav Teplitskiy	949-721-5308
68287	Paul Stellman	415-954-4114
68306	William Adams	949-760-0404
68316	Jason Champion	949-760-0404
68329	Daniel Gibson	949-760-0404
68430	Vladimir Lozan	949-721-2828
68578	Thomas Cowan	858-707-4000
68587	Viswanathan Lakshmanan	415-954-4114
69133	Stephen Larson	949-760-0404
69282	Heungsoo Choi	858-707-4000
70224	Robert Hilton	858-707-4000
70256	Damien Howard	949-760-0404
70367	Adam Powell	650-752-1100
70451	Mark Rubinshtein	858-707-4000
70611	Karen Marie Cassidy	949-721-5302
70780	Bryan Mcwhorter	206-405-2000
71099	Justin Gillett	949-760-0404
71587	Hans Mayer	949-760-0404
71679	Daniel Kamkar	858-707-4180
71691	Makoto Tsunozaki	415-954-4114
71933	Jordan Gottdank	858-707-4000
72423	Brian Graham	415-814-6161
72722	Peter Law	858-707-4243
73097	Harnik Shukla	949-760-0404
73126	David Schmidt	949-721-6386
73564	Alexander Zeng	949-721-5293
74164	Aaron Johnson	949-395-4097
74343	Kjersten Bakke	608-257-3501
74752	Aryeh Feinstein	202-640-6408
74897	Douglas Wentzel	856-285-4688
74907	Dominic Filice	650-849-3061
75143	Michelle Ziperstein	310-407-3475
75150	Clayton Henson	858-707-4000
75231	Paul Spiel	206-405-2032
75319	Alexander Martinez	949-760-0404
75684	Jessica Achtsam	949-760-0404
75686	Jeremy Anapol	949-721-2806
75717	Jeremy Carney	949-760-0404
75733	Katherine Mcmorrow	310-407-3460
75805	Brian Barnes	949-721-5242
76047	Inzer Ni	212-849-3044
76130	Tyler Cox	415-217-3516
76238	Mitchell Hadley	212-849-3013
76314	David Cohen	949-760-0404
76416	Spencer Carter	949-760-0404
76592	Daniel Hughes	858-707-4000
76821	Charles Choi	718-807-5825
77014	Justin Culbertson	202-640-6400
77396	Paige Radtke	949-760-0404
77474	Alistair Mcintyre	858-707-4102
77499	Samuel Cockriel	949-760-0404
77806	Nathan Reeves	206-405-2000
77839	Zachary Messick	858-707-4000
78415	Rhett Ramsey	949-721-2932
78566	Douglas Crandell	858-707-4253
78620	Brian Flynn	858-707-4187
79031	Christopher Lewis	202-640-6433
79046	Xiaoyan Wang	949-760-0404
79108	Lindsay Laddaran	949-721-2893
79146	Serah Friedman	310-825-1097
79325	Luke Holbrook	949-721-2929
79515	John Hendershott	208-908-3032
79610	Jose Martin Del Campo	949-721-5340
79631	Daniel Kiang	949-760-0404
79683	Eric Abada	415-217-3515
79744	Erin Cardinal	202-640-6417
79750	Daniel Mittelstein	949-760-0404
79783	Janet Allendorph	858-707-4000
79806	Charles Sirek	949-760-0404
80009	Christian Boettcher	714-236-0444
80052	Timothy Trost	213-509-3803
80282	Brianne Kingery	801-203-3546
80326	Ashley Morales	858-707-4022
80623	Gregory Munchinsky	858-707-4000
80915	Susan Janicki	946-760-0404
80919	Emmett Litvak	91-124-280-6101
L1081	Stacy Rush	646-575-6066

Proceeding Documents

104

Notice: refund approved NOTICE

2024-08-20 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Petitioners Request for Refund OTHER

2024-08-06 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Institution Decision: Deny DECISION

2024-07-09 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Patent Owner's Preliminary Sur-Reply OTHER

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER

Download

1075

Joint Letter for March 20, 2024 Case Management Conference Exhibit

2024-05-20 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Apple Inc. vs. Masimo Corporation

Proceeding Overview

Parties & Counsel

Petitioner

Apple Inc.

Represented By

Patent Owner / Respondent

Masimo Corporation

Represented By

Tribunal & Venue

Patent Information

Address and Attorney/Agent Information

Power of Attorney & Correspondence

Attorney / Agent Information

Proceeding Documents

Notice: refund approved NOTICE

Petitioners Request for Refund OTHER

Institution Decision: Deny DECISION

Patent Owner's Preliminary Sur-Reply OTHER

Joint Letter for March 20, 2024 Case Management Conference Exhibit

Petitioners Reply to Patent Owners Preliminary Response OTHER

Sotera Stipulation by Apple Inc. Exhibit

Federal Court Management Statistics Exhibit

Median Time to Disposition Exhibit

Final Written Decision (Public Version), Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01465 (Feb. 2, 2024) Exhibit

Patent Owner's Response to Petitioner's Notices Ranking Petitions OTHER

Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1466, Paper 17 Exhibit

Expert Declaration of Vijay K. Madisetti Exhibit

Plaintiff Apple Inc.’s Opposition to Defendants’ Motion for Stay Pending Inter Partes Review (Public), Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., No. 22-1378-MN-JLH Exhibit

Amended Scheduling Order, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., No. 22-1378-MN-JLH Exhibit

Correspondence from counsel for Apple to counsel for Masimo regarding Apple’s prior art grounds in the Delaware Litigation, dated November 16, 2023 Exhibit

June 6–10, 2022 Public Hearing Transcript, ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 Exhibit

Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1271, Paper 20 Exhibit

Lex Machina Patent Case Timeline Statistics for the District of Delaware between December 12, 2022 and December 12, 2023 Exhibit

Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01274, Paper 15 Exhibit

Apple Inc.’s Post-Hearing Brief (Public Version), ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 Exhibit

Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01275, Paper 15 Exhibit

Redacted Excerpt of the December 15, 2023 Rebuttal Report of Dr. Majid Sarrafzadeh Exhibit

Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1273, Paper 19 Exhibit

Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01271, Paper 15 Exhibit

Commission Opinion (Public), Certain Light-Based Physiological Measurement Devices and Components Thereof, Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 Exhibit

Excerpts of File History of App. No. 15/195,199 - Part 2 Exhibit

Joint Claim Construction Statement Regarding Masimo Asserted Patents, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., No. 22-1378-MN-JLH Exhibit

Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE

Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1292, Paper 17 Exhibit

Masimo Post-Hearing Brief (Public Version), ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 Exhibit

Curriculum Vitae of Vijay K. Madisetti Exhibit

November 17, 2023 Letter from U.S. Food & Drug Administration to Masimo Corp. re Masimo W1 510(k) Clearance Exhibit

Plaintiff Apple Inc.’s Opening Brief in Support of Its Motion for an Expedited Trial, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., No. 22-1377-MN-JLH Exhibit

Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1276, Paper 20 Exhibit

Aaron Tilley, The Entrepreneur Who Bet His Company on a Fight With Apple, Wall Street J., Dec. 30, 2023 Exhibit

Lex Machina Case Statistics for Judges Exhibit

Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1275, Paper 19 Exhibit

Masimo Post-Hearing Brief (Public Version), ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 -Part 1 Exhibit

Emails dated August–September 2022 between Apple’s and Masimo’s Counsel re IPR2022-01291 and -01465 Exhibit

Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01273, Paper 15 Exhibit

Transcript of May 5, 2023 Hearing in Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., Nos. 22-1377-MN-JLH, 22-1378-MN-JLH Exhibit

Nonconfidential Excerpt of Page 65 from June 6-10, 2022 Hearing Transcript, ITC Inv. No 337-TA-1276 Exhibit

Order re Conduct of the Proceedings, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01291, Order Conduct of the Proceedings Exhibit

Patent Owner Preliminary Response POPR

Original Scheduling Order, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., No. 22-1378-MN-JLH Exhibit

Lex Machina Case Statistics for Magistrate Judge Jennifer Hall Exhibit

Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1274, Paper 19 Exhibit

Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01276, Paper 15 Exhibit

Final Written Decision (Public Version), Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01291 (Jan. 30, 2024) Exhibit

Transcript of September 14, 2023 Markman Hearing, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., Nos. 22-cv-1377-MN-JLH, 22-cv-1378-MN-JLH Exhibit

Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01272 Exhibit

Excerpts of File History of App. No. 15/195,199 - Part 1 Exhibit

Masimo Post-Hearing Brief (Public Version), ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 - Part 2 Exhibit

Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1272, Paper 20 Exhibit

Email chain regarding false statements in IPR Petitions Exhibit

Masimo Post-Hearing Brief (Public Version), ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 - Part 4 Exhibit

Petition for Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01292 Exhibit

Excerpt of Webster’s II New College Dictionary (2001) Exhibit

Masimo Post-Hearing Brief (Public Version), ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 - Part 3 Exhibit

Masimo Post-Hearing Brief (Public Version), ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-1276 - Part 5 Exhibit

Petition for Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01466 Exhibit

Excerpt of Apple’s Final Invalidity Contentions, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., No. 1:22-cv-1378-JLH Exhibit

Excerpts of File History of App. No. 16/532,065 Exhibit

Petitioner’s Reply (Public Version), Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01291 Exhibit