Apple Inc. vs. Masimo Corporation
Explore the PTAB proceeding IPR2024-00294 filed by Apple Inc. on 2023-12-12. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.
Proceeding Overview
Proceeding Number
IPR2024-00294
Filing Date
2023-12-12
Accorded Filing Date
2023-12-12
Institution Decision Date
2024-06-27
Last Modified Date
2025-09-03
Proceeding Type
IPR
Termination Date
2025-06-26
Trial Status
Final Written Decision
Parties & Counsel
Petitioner
Apple Inc.
Represented By
Renner, W. Karlet alPatent Owner / Respondent
Masimo Corporation
Represented By
Claassen, Brianet alTribunal & Venue
Tribunal
Patent Trial and Appeal Board (USPTO)
Technology Center
TC 3700 - Mechanical Engineering & Manufacturing
Patent Information
Respondent Application Number
15880071
Respondent Patent Number
10736507
External Links
Respondent Inventor
Bilal Muhsin et al
Respondent Tech Center
TC 3700 - Mechanical Engineering & Manufacturing
Address and Attorney/Agent Information
Power of Attorney & Correspondence
Firm
/ Entity Name
Knobbe, Martens, Olson & Bear, LLP - MASIMO CORPORATION (MASIMO)
Customer
Number
64735
Address
2040 MAIN STREET, FOURTEENTH FLOOR, IRVINE, CA, 92614, UNITED STATES
Attorney / Agent Information
| Reg # | Name | Phone |
|---|---|---|
| 31291 | Joseph Re | 949-760-0404 |
| 31430 | Craig Summers | 949-760-0404 |
| 32297 | Edward Schlatter | 949-760-0404 |
| 34115 | Daniel Altman | 949-760-0404 |
| 34362 | John King | 949-760-0404 |
| 35556 | Stephen Jensen | 949-760-0404 |
| 36516 | Michael Fuller | 858-707-4000 |
| 37688 | Steven Nataupsky | 949-760-0404 |
| 37924 | Raimond Salenieks | 858-707-4000 |
| 39287 | Joseph Mallon | 858-707-4000 |
| 39901 | Neil Bartfeld | 858-707-4202 |
| 40574 | Maria Anderson | 206-405-2000 |
| 40664 | Joseph Jennings | 949-760-0404 |
| 41371 | David Weiss | 310-551-3450 |
| 41394 | Adeel Akhtar | 415-954-4114 |
| 42610 | John Grover | 949-760-0404 |
| 42856 | Thomas Mcclenahan | 949-297-7074 |
| 43622 | Mark Gallagher | 949-760-0404 |
| 43745 | Sabing Lee | 949-760-0404 |
| 43878 | Joseph Reisman | 858-707-4000 |
| 44087 | Paul Conover | 949-760-0404 |
| 44328 | Melanie Seelig | 206-405-2000 |
| 45664 | Eric Furman | 858-707-4000 |
| 46206 | Mauricio Uribe | 206-405-2000 |
| 46547 | Matthew Bellinger | 949-760-0404 |
| 47677 | Bruce Itchkawitz | 949-760-0404 |
| 48877 | Curtis Huffmire | 949-760-0404 |
| 51212 | Andrew Douglas | 949-760-0404 |
| 51240 | Linda Liu | 949-760-0404 |
| 51241 | James Herkenhoff | 6503282844 |
| 51754 | Christy Green | 949-760-0404 |
| 51922 | Irfan Lateef | 949-721-7672 |
| 52082 | Perry Oldham | 949-721-2961 |
| 53018 | Gregory Hermanson | 858-707-4000 |
| 53084 | Mark Kachner | 310-551-3450 |
| 53102 | Benjamin Katzenellenbogen | (617) 499-6200 |
| 53317 | Andrew Merickel | 415-954-4114 |
| 53428 | Yichuan Pan | 858-707-4000 |
| 53658 | Sheila Swaroop | 949-760-0404 |
| 54198 | Russell Jeide | 949-760-0404 |
| 54511 | Josue Villalta | 949-760-0404 |
| 54618 | Karen Lenker | 949-760-0404 |
| 55030 | Cheryl Burgess | 949-721-2935 |
| 55036 | Ted Cannon | 949-760-0404 |
| 55310 | Agnes Juang | 949-760-0404 |
| 55634 | Raymond Smith | 949-760-0404 |
| 56553 | Lauren Keller | 949-721-6365 |
| 57046 | Jarom Kesler | 949-760-0404 |
| 57505 | Michael Christensen | 949-760-0404 |
| 57571 | Maria Stout | 858-707-4000 |
| 57871 | Mark Marsden | 858-707-4000 |
| 58474 | Jared Bunker | 949-760-0404 |
| 58621 | Ryan Melnick | 858-707-4000 |
| 58855 | Andrew Kimmel | 949-760-0404 |
| 59362 | Lincoln Essig | 202-640-6400 |
| 59406 | David Trossen | 415-954-4114 |
| 59856 | Terry Tullis | 949-760-0404 |
| 60295 | Brenden Gingrich | 858-707-4000 |
| 60659 | Benjamin Everton | 949-760-0404 |
| 60771 | Ali Razai | 949-760-0404 |
| 60934 | Christopher Ross | 949-760-0404 |
| 61224 | Carol Pitzel Cruz | 206-405-2000 |
| 61513 | Colin Heideman | 206-405-2000 |
| 61546 | Theodore Papagiannis | 949-760-0404 |
| 61557 | Nicholas Zovko | 949-760-0404 |
| 61569 | Qian Dai | 858-707-4000 |
| 61595 | Susan Natland | 949-760-0404 |
| 61749 | Kimberly Miller | 858-707-4000 |
| 61805 | Jason Jardine | 858-707-4000 |
| 62027 | Aaron Davis | 415-954-4114 |
| 62207 | Benjamin Anger | 858-707-4000 |
| 62280 | Ian Gillies | 858-707-4000 |
| 62676 | Philip Nelson | 949-760-0404 |
| 62933 | Christie Matthaei | 206-405-2000 |
| 63035 | Kregg Koch | 310-551-3450 |
| 63051 | Brian Claassen | 949-760-0404 |
| 63106 | Chang Lim | 949-760-0404 |
| 63160 | Nathanael Luman | 858-836-9000 |
| 63635 | Alan Laquer | 949-760-0404 |
| 63934 | Jeffery Hallstrom | 949-760-0404 |
| 64096 | Joshua Stowell | 949-760-9562 |
| 64420 | Jason Swartz | 609/734-6888 |
| 64970 | Morgan Coates | 949-760-0404 |
| 65026 | Devanie Dufour | 202-640-6400 |
| 65066 | Scott Cromar | 949-721-2812 |
| 65096 | Jacob Peterson | 206-274-6400 |
| 65157 | Laura Hall | 949-721-7686 |
| 65290 | Sean Ambrosius | 949-760-0404 |
| 65562 | Derek Dailey | 858-707-4000 |
| 65614 | Shannon Lam | 949-760-0404 |
| 65642 | Andrea Cheek | 202-640-6400 |
| 65994 | Marko Zoretic | 949-760-0404 |
| 66152 | Lance Smemoe | 949-760-0404 |
| 66226 | Derek Bayles | 949-760-0404 |
| 66385 | Joan Chan | 949-760-0404 |
| 66766 | Andrew Lloyd | 949-760-0404 |
| 67249 | Kyu Min | 415-954-4114 |
| 67720 | Salima Merani | 949-760-0404 |
| 67824 | Hochan Song | 949-760-0404 |
| 67884 | Jonathan Bachand | 202-640-6400 |
| 68005 | Vikas Bhargava | 949-760-0404 |
| 68069 | Vladislav Teplitskiy | 949-721-5308 |
| 68287 | Paul Stellman | 415-954-4114 |
| 68306 | William Adams | 949-760-0404 |
| 68316 | Jason Champion | 949-760-0404 |
| 68329 | Daniel Gibson | 949-760-0404 |
| 68430 | Vladimir Lozan | 949-721-2828 |
| 68578 | Thomas Cowan | 858-707-4000 |
| 68587 | Viswanathan Lakshmanan | 415-954-4114 |
| 69133 | Stephen Larson | 949-760-0404 |
| 69282 | Heungsoo Choi | 858-707-4000 |
| 70224 | Robert Hilton | 858-707-4000 |
| 70256 | Damien Howard | 949-760-0404 |
| 70367 | Adam Powell | 650-752-1100 |
| 70451 | Mark Rubinshtein | 858-707-4000 |
| 70611 | Karen Marie Cassidy | 949-721-5302 |
| 70780 | Bryan Mcwhorter | 206-405-2000 |
| 71099 | Justin Gillett | 949-760-0404 |
| 71587 | Hans Mayer | 949-760-0404 |
| 71679 | Daniel Kamkar | 858-707-4180 |
| 71691 | Makoto Tsunozaki | 415-954-4114 |
| 71933 | Jordan Gottdank | 858-707-4000 |
| 72423 | Brian Graham | 415-814-6161 |
| 72722 | Peter Law | 858-707-4243 |
| 73097 | Harnik Shukla | 949-760-0404 |
| 73126 | David Schmidt | 949-721-6386 |
| 73564 | Alexander Zeng | 949-721-5293 |
| 74164 | Aaron Johnson | 949-395-4097 |
| 74343 | Kjersten Bakke | 608-257-3501 |
| 74752 | Aryeh Feinstein | 202-640-6408 |
| 74897 | Douglas Wentzel | 856-285-4688 |
| 74907 | Dominic Filice | 650-849-3061 |
| 75143 | Michelle Ziperstein | 310-407-3475 |
| 75150 | Clayton Henson | 858-707-4000 |
| 75231 | Paul Spiel | 206-405-2032 |
| 75319 | Alexander Martinez | 949-760-0404 |
| 75684 | Jessica Achtsam | 949-760-0404 |
| 75686 | Jeremy Anapol | 949-721-2806 |
| 75717 | Jeremy Carney | 949-760-0404 |
| 75733 | Katherine Mcmorrow | 310-407-3460 |
| 75805 | Brian Barnes | 949-721-5242 |
| 76047 | Inzer Ni | 212-849-3044 |
| 76130 | Tyler Cox | 415-217-3516 |
| 76238 | Mitchell Hadley | 212-849-3013 |
| 76314 | David Cohen | 949-760-0404 |
| 76416 | Spencer Carter | 949-760-0404 |
| 76592 | Daniel Hughes | 858-707-4000 |
| 76821 | Charles Choi | 718-807-5825 |
| 77014 | Justin Culbertson | 202-640-6400 |
| 77396 | Paige Radtke | 949-760-0404 |
| 77474 | Alistair Mcintyre | 858-707-4102 |
| 77499 | Samuel Cockriel | 949-760-0404 |
| 77806 | Nathan Reeves | 206-405-2000 |
| 77839 | Zachary Messick | 858-707-4000 |
| 78415 | Rhett Ramsey | 949-721-2932 |
| 78566 | Douglas Crandell | 858-707-4253 |
| 78620 | Brian Flynn | 858-707-4187 |
| 79031 | Christopher Lewis | 202-640-6433 |
| 79046 | Xiaoyan Wang | 949-760-0404 |
| 79108 | Lindsay Laddaran | 949-721-2893 |
| 79146 | Serah Friedman | 310-825-1097 |
| 79325 | Luke Holbrook | 949-721-2929 |
| 79515 | John Hendershott | 208-908-3032 |
| 79610 | Jose Martin Del Campo | 949-721-5340 |
| 79631 | Daniel Kiang | 949-760-0404 |
| 79683 | Eric Abada | 415-217-3515 |
| 79744 | Erin Cardinal | 202-640-6417 |
| 79750 | Daniel Mittelstein | 949-760-0404 |
| 79783 | Janet Allendorph | 858-707-4000 |
| 79806 | Charles Sirek | 949-760-0404 |
| 80009 | Christian Boettcher | 714-236-0444 |
| 80052 | Timothy Trost | 213-509-3803 |
| 80282 | Brianne Kingery | 801-203-3546 |
| 80326 | Ashley Morales | 858-707-4022 |
| 80623 | Gregory Munchinsky | 858-707-4000 |
| 80915 | Susan Janicki | 946-760-0404 |
| 80919 | Emmett Litvak | 91-124-280-6101 |
| L1081 | Stacy Rush | 646-575-6066 |
Proceeding Documents
200
66
JUDGMENT Final Written Decision Determining All Challenged Claims Unpatentable Denying Patent Owner’s Contingent Motion to Amend 35 U.S.C. § 318(a) Dismissing Petitioner’s Motion to Strike 37 C.F.R. § 42.23 FINAL
2025-06-26
FILING PARTY: BOARD
65
Other: Hearing transcript OTHER
2025-06-25
FILING PARTY: BOARD
62
Notice of Intent to Designate Micheal Amon NOTICE
2025-06-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1136
Declaration of Michael Amon Exhibit
2025-06-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
64
Updated Mandatory Notice NOTICE
2025-06-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
63
Updated Power of Attorney NOTICE
2025-06-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
2039
Prototype Video_mp4 Format (last modified August 31, 2011) Exhibit
2025-05-23
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
1135
Petitioners Demonstratives Exhibit
2025-05-19
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
2059
Patent Owner's Demonstratives Exhibit
2025-05-19
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
61
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
2025-05-19
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
60
Petitioners Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
2025-05-19
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
3006
e-mail authorizing filing of motion to strike Exhibit
2025-05-15
FILING PARTY: BOARD
58
Petitioners Sur-Reply to Patent Owners Reply OTHER
2025-05-15
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
59
Petitioners Observations OTHER
2025-05-15
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1134
Transcript of the Deposition of Dr. R. James Duckworth Exhibit
2025-05-15
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
57
Order: Setting Oral Argument - 37 CFR 42.70 ORDER
2025-05-08
FILING PARTY: BOARD
55
Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument OTHER
2025-05-06
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
56
Patent Owner Request for Oral Argument NOTICE
2025-05-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
54
Notice of Deposition of R. James Duckworth, Ph.D. NOTICE
2025-05-05
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
53
Patent Owner’s Reply To Petitioner’s Opposition To Patent Owner’s Revised Motion To Amend REPLY
2025-04-24
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2058
Declaration Of R. James Duckworth, Ph.D. Exhibit
2025-04-24
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
1115
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2009/0149299 to Tchao et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1124
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2004/0089570 to Chien et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1118
PCT Pub. No. WO2011/127446 to Soden et al. Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1119
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2010/0113950 to Lin et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1112
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2006/0211924 to Dalke et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1123
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2005/0265668 to Martin Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1120
U.S. Patent No. 6,970,792 to Diab Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1117
U.S. Patent No. 6,443,614 to Read Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1110
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2011/0082711 to Poeze et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1131
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2009/0171170 to Li et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1133
Pomona Model 3301 Size F Extruded Aluminum Box With Cover specification (1999) Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1127
U.S. Patent No. 7,649,741 to Liu Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1130
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2010/0004522 to Varela Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1125
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2011/0194234 to Kim et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1109
Third Declaration of Dr. Thomas Kenny Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1126
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2011/0216482 to Moscovitch et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1132
Pomona Model 3231 Size B Aluminum Box With Cover BNC Male/Female specification (1999) Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1121
U.S. Patent No. 7,712,970 to Lee Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1129
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 20120122519 to Jochheim Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1113
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2011/0187245 to Pakula et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1111
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2010/0030040 to Poeze et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1128
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2008/0223892 to Hamilton Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1114
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2003/0176815 to Baba et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1116
U.S. Patent Application Pub. No. 2011/0003665 to Burton et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1122
U.S. Patent No. 6,869,315 to Nakai et al Exhibit
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
52
Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Revised Motion to Amend OTHER
2025-04-03
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
51
Patent Owner's Opposition to Motion to Strike OPPOSITION
2025-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
50
Petitioner's Motion to Strike MOTION
2025-03-21
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
49
ORDER Conduct of the Proceeding 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.5 and 42.121(a) ORDER
2025-03-13
FILING PARTY: BOARD
3005
E-mail from counsel Exhibit
2025-03-12
FILING PARTY: BOARD
3004
March 10, 2025 conference call transcript Exhibit
2025-03-12
FILING PARTY: BOARD
2056
33rd Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC ’11) Exhibit
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2057
Deposition transcript of Gordon Macpherson February 27, 2025 Exhibit
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2053
IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society Annual International Conference. 2011 (EMBC 2011) (DVD) Exhibit
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2052
IEEE Contact & Support Page Exhibit
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2055
Preparing Conference Proceedings for Attendees Exhibit
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
47
Masimo's Sur-Reply OTHER
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2054
IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society Annual International Conference. 2011 (EMBC 2011) (17 Vols) Exhibit
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
48
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2051
Subpoena to testify Exhibit
2025-03-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
46
REVISED SCHEDULING ORDER NOTICE
2025-03-05
FILING PARTY: BOARD
45
Patent Owner Updated Mandatory Notices Information NOTICE
2025-02-25
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
44
Notice of Stipulation to Modify Masimo's Sur-Reply Due Date NOTICE
2025-02-21
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
43
Notice of Deposition of Gordon MacPherson NOTICE
2025-02-21
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
42
Patent Owner's Revised Contingent Motion to Amend OTHER
2025-02-20
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
41
Notice of Stipulation to Modify Masimo's Sur-Reply Due Date NOTICE
2025-02-18
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
40
Order: Authorization to Apply for Subpoena from Federal District Court - 35 USC 24 and 37 CFR 42.52(a) ORDER
2025-02-14
FILING PARTY: BOARD
3003
E-mail requesting subpoena Exhibit
2025-02-14
FILING PARTY: BOARD
39
ORDER Conduct of the Proceeding 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.5 ORDER
2025-02-12
FILING PARTY: BOARD
3002
Exhibit 3002 Exhibit
2025-02-12
FILING PARTY: BOARD
38
Petitioners Motion to Compel Testimony MOTION
2025-02-11
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
37
Petitioners Request for Oral Argument OTHER
2025-02-06
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
36
Patent Owner Masimo Corporation Request for Oral Argument OTHER
2025-02-06
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
35
Notice of Stipulation to Modify Due Date NOTICE
2025-02-05
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
34
Patent Owner Masimo Corporation's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Thomas Kenny NOTICE
2025-01-30
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
33
Notice: Preliminary Guidance NOTICE
2025-01-29
FILING PARTY: BOARD
2050
Deposition Errata of James Duckworth Exhibit
2025-01-27
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
32
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
2025-01-27
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
1093
U.S. Publication No. 2013/0069431 to Tseng Exhibit
2025-01-22
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1093
US 2013/0069431 to Tseng et al. Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1087
Transcript of the Deposition of Dr. R. James Duckworth Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1086
Response_The New Penguin Dictionary Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1097
Karlen_Human-Centered Phone Oximeter Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1101
US 7,650,176 to Sarussi et al. Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1095
Sankman_Development of a Remote Pulse Oximeter Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1100
US 2010/0146463 to Cho et al. Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
31
Petitioners Opposition to PO Motion to Amend OTHER
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1084
Responsive_Chambers Concise Dictionary Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1092
US 7,598,878 to Goldreich Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1094
Hudson_Usability Testing of a Prototype Phone Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1091
US 2006/0253010 to Brady et al. Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1102
US 7,468,036 to Rulkov et al. Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1107
Transcript of the Deposition of Bilal Muhsin Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1104
US 2007/0173705 to Teller et al. Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1082
Declaration of Gordon MacPherson Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1103
US 2009/0231960 to Hutcheson Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1106
Shah_PDA based ambulatory pulse oximeter Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1085
Responsive_Bloomsbury English Dictionary Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1099
Nonin_Xpod External EOM Pulse Oximeter Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1083
Second Declaration of Dr. Thomas Kenny Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
30
Petitioners Reply to Patent Owners Response REPLYTOOPP
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1108
Second Declaration of June Munford Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1105
US 2007/0016053 to Lo et al. Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1098
Press Release Xpod Exhibit
2025-01-13
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
29
Updated Notice of Deposition of Bilal Muhsin NOTICE
2025-01-06
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
28
Notice of Deposition of Bilal Muhsin NOTICE
2025-01-02
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
3001
Ex. 3001 Exhibit
2024-12-20
FILING PARTY: BOARD
27
Order: Conduct of the Proceeding ORDER
2024-12-20
FILING PARTY: BOARD
26
Notice of Deposition of R. James Duckworth, Ph.D. NOTICE
2024-12-06
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
25
Order Conduct of the Proceeding ORDER
2024-11-15
FILING PARTY: BOARD
24
PATENT OWNER’S SUR-REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS OPPOSITION TO PETITIONER’S MOTION TO STRIKE OTHER
2024-11-08
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
23
Petitioner's Reply to Patent Owner's Opposition OTHER
2024-11-05
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
2048
Email Record of Parties’ Correspondence with the Board Prior to Filing Motion to Amend Exhibit
2024-11-01
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2049
Patent Trial and Appeal Board Consolidated Trial Practice Guide, November 2019 Exhibit
2024-11-01
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
22
Patent Owner's Opposition to Motion to Strike OPPOSITION
2024-11-01
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
1081
Email Record of Meet-and-Confer Regarding Motion to Strike Exhibit
2024-10-29
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1080
Email Record of Meet-and-Confer Regarding Deadline Extensions Exhibit
2024-10-29
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1079
Board Email Authorizing Motion to Strike and Evidence Exhibit
2024-10-29
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
21
Petitioners Motion to Strike Patent Owners Motion to Amend MOTION
2024-10-29
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
20
Patent Owner's Updated Submission of Mandatory Notice Information NOTICE
2024-10-24
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2045
U.S. Patent App. No. 15/880,071 Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2039
Prototype Video (last modified August 31, 2011) Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
17
Patent Owner Response RESPONSE
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2040
User Interface Summary (last modified August 31, 2011) Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2047
U.S. Patent App. No. 14/033,315 Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
19
Patent Owner's Updated Exhibit List NOTICE
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2038
Declaration of Bilal Muhsin Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2044
Deposition Transcript of Thomas Kenny, Ph.D. Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2042
iSpO2 Image cited in Exhibit 2041 Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2037
October 10, 2024 Expert Declaration of R. James Duckworth, Ph.D. Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
18
Patent Owner's Contingent Motion to Amend MOTION
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2043
IEEE Xplore Webpage for D’Angelo Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2046
U.S. Prov. Patent App. No. 61/703,729 Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2041
Masimo iSpO2™ Pulse Oximeter for iOS Platform (iPhone, iPad & iPod touch) for Consumers to Debut at CES, Jan. 3, 2013 Exhibit
2024-10-10
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
16
Notice of Stipulation to Modify Due Date NOTICE
2024-09-13
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
15
Patent Owner's Notice of Deposition of Dr. Thomas Kenny NOTICE
2024-08-09
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
14
Notice of Stipulation to Modify Due Dates NOTICE
2024-08-09
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
13
Patent Owner's Updated Mandatory Notices NOTICE
2024-08-08
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
11
Institution Decision: Grant DECISION
2024-06-27
FILING PARTY: BOARD
12
SCHEDULING ORDER ORDER
2024-06-27
FILING PARTY: BOARD
10
Patent Owner's Preliminary Sur-Reply OTHER
2024-05-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
1078
Sotera Stipulation by Apple Inc. Exhibit
2024-05-20
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
9
Petitioners Reply to Patent Owners Preliminary Response OTHER
2024-05-20
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1077
Median Time to Disposition Exhibit
2024-05-20
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1075
Joint Letter for March 20, 2024 Case Management Conference Exhibit
2024-05-20
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1076
Federal Court Management Statistics Exhibit
2024-05-20
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
2031
Excerpts of the Rebuttal Expert Report of Steven Warren in Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2029
Joint Claim Construction Briefing (August 31, 2023) in Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2035
Exhibit D-3 to Apple’s June 8, 2023 Initial Invalidity Contentions, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2026
Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1292, Paper 17 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2009
Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01276 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2018
Transcript of September 14, 2023 Markman Hearing, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2015
Lex Machina Patent Case Timeline Statistics for the District of Delaware Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2032
Blood Oxygen App On Apple Watch, Apple (retrieved March 12, 2024) Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2008
Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01275 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2036
Excerpts of Masimo’s June 22, 2023 Responses to Apple Inc.’s Initial Invalidity Contentions, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2034
Exhibit D-1 to Apple’s June 8, 2023 Initial Invalidity Contentions, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2014
Amended Scheduling Order, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp. Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2033
CC1100 Single Chip Low Cost Low Power RF Transceiver, Texas Instruments (June 20, 2006) Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2021
Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1272, Paper 20 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2027
Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1466, Paper 17 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2005
Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01272 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2006
Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01273 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2011
Plaintiff Apple Inc.’s Opening Brief in Support of Its Motion for an Expedited Trial, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
7
Patent Owner Preliminary Response POPR
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2030
Excerpts of the Transcript of the Deposition of Steven Warren in Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2002
Expert Declaration Of R. James Duckworth, Ph.D. Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2013
Original Scheduling Order, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2012
Transcript of May 5, 2023 Hearing in Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2025
Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1276, Paper 20 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2019
Aaron Tilley, The Entrepreneur Who Bet His Company on a Fight With Apple, Wall Street J., Dec. 30, 2023 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2017
Lex Machina Case Statistics Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2010
Plaintiff Apple Inc.’s Opposition to Defendants’ Motion for Stay Pending Inter Partes Review (Public), Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp. Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2007
Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01274 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2028
Correspondence from counsel for Apple to counsel for Masimo regarding Apple’s prior art grounds Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2016
Lex Machina Case Statistics for Magistrate Judge Jennifer Hall Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2023
Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1274, Paper 19 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2003
Commission Opinion (Public), Certain Light-Based Physiological Measurement Devices and Components Thereof Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2024
Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1275, Paper 19 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
8
Patent Owner's Response to Petitioner's Notices Ranking Petitions NOTICE
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2020
Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1271, Paper 20 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2004
Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-01271 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2022
Notice of Refund, Apple Inc. v. Masimo Corp., IPR2022-1273, Paper 19 Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
2001
R. James Duckworth, Ph.D. Curriculum Vitae Exhibit
2024-03-28
FILING PARTY: PATENT OWNER
6
Petitioners Updated Mandatory Notice NOTICE
2024-03-11
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
4
Notice: Notice filing date accorded NOTICE
2023-12-28
FILING PARTY: BOARD
1063
Complaint for Patent Infringement_1-22-cv-01378 Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1001
U.S. Patent No. 10,736,507 Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
3
Petition for Inter Partes Review of U.S. Patent 10,736,507 PETITION
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1060
U.S. Court Management Statistics Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1067
Email Identifying District Court Invalidity Grounds Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1066
Stipulation by Apple Inc. Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1010
U.S. Publication No. 2010/0324387 to Moon Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1002
U.S. Patent No. 10,736,507 File History Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1014
Exemplary Infringement Claim Chart_507 patent Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1068
Excerpt of Apple's District Court Expert Invalidity Report Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1062
Complaint for Patent Infringement_1-22-cv-01377 Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1008
U.S. Patent No. 7,812,826 to Ording Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
1012
Declaration of June Munford Exhibit
2023-12-12
FILING PARTY: PETITIONER
Download Proceeding Documents
Case IPR2024-00294 • 200 documents
Preparing ZIP Archive
Email verified! Bundling proceeding documents from USPTO. Your download will start automatically in a few seconds...