Dell Technologies Inc. et al. vs. LiTL LLC

Explore the PTAB proceeding IPR2024-00481 filed by Dell Technologies Inc. et al. on 2024-01-29. This includes filing dates, application numbers, tech centers, patent numbers, and current case status.

Proceeding Overview

Proceeding Number

IPR2024-00481

Filing Date

2024-01-29

Accorded Filing Date

2024-01-29

Institution Decision Date

2024-05-28

Last Modified Date

2025-01-27

Proceeding Type

IPR

Termination Date

2024-05-28

Trial Status

Institution Denied

Parties & Counsel

Petitioner

Dell Technologies Inc. et al.

Represented By

Day, Jameset al

Patent Owner / Respondent

LiTL LLC

Represented By

Giunta, Richardet al

Tribunal & Venue

Tribunal

Patent Trial and Appeal Board (USPTO)

Technology Center

TC 2800 - Semiconductors, Electrical & Optical Systems

Patent Information

1 Patent Involved

Respondent Application Number 13651636

Respondent Patent Number 9563229

External Links

Espacenet

Google Patents

Respondent Inventor Yves Behar et al

Respondent Tech Center TC 2800 - Semiconductors, Electrical & Optical Systems

Address and Attorney/Agent Information

119 Registered Practitioners

Power of Attorney & Correspondence

Firm / Entity Name WOLF GREENFIELD & SACKS, P.C.

Customer Number 23628

Address 600 ATLANTIC AVENUE, BOSTON, MA, 02210-2206, UNITED STATES

Attorney / Agent Information

Reg #	Name	Phone
28129	John Welch	617-646-8000
31616	Edward Gates	617-646-8000
31624	Jason Honeyman	617-646-8222
32950	Edmund Walsh	617-646-8000
34681	James Morris	617-646-8000
35986	Randy Pritzker	617-646-8000
36149	Richard Giunta	617-646-8000
36628	Timothy Oyer	617-646-8251
36971	Douglas Wolf	617-646-8260
38232	Robert Maldonado	212-849-3339
39188	Neil Ferraro	617-646-8267
39213	James Hanifin Jr	617-646-8000
39231	Robert Hunt	617-646-8000
39248	Helen Lockhart	617-646-8249
40024	Jeffrey Hsi	617-646-8556
40212	John Van Amsterdam	617-646-8000
40286	Stephen Rabinowitz	212-849-3356
41418	Patrick Waller	617-646-8000
42866	Scott Mckeown	202-389-6025
43069	Edward Russavage	617-646-8515
43988	Adam Wichman	617-646-8571
46190	Michael Pomianek	617-646-8000
46324	Robert Walat	617-646-8000
46533	Charles Baker	617-646-8381
48207	Maria Trevisan	617-646-8000
48644	Andrew Williams	617-646-8000
50474	Gerald Hrycyszyn	617-646-8313
52146	Michael Rader	617-646-8000
52318	Janice Vatland	617-646-8000
52728	Tani Chen	617-646-8214
52957	Matthew Grady	617-646-8000
54986	Melissa Beede	617-646-8000
55151	Roque El Hayek	617-646-8000
57063	Gregory Nieberg	212-849-3338
58404	Tonia Sayour	212-697-7890
58423	Gabriel Mccool	617-646-8000
58767	Michael Parsons	617-646-8942
59924	Nidhi Malla	617-646-8572
61115	Jonathan Roses	617-646-8157
61146	Robert Jensen	617-646-8271
61674	Jessamine Lee	617-646-8272
62868	Daniel Young	617-646-8245
63390	Zachary Piccolomini	617-646-8579
63456	Thomas Franklin	617-646-8000
64978	Marc Johannes	617-646-8209
65507	Robert Sahr	617-646-8484
65843	Heather Dipietrantonio	617-646-8000
66229	Victor Cheung	202-571-5012
66256	Brandon Blackwell	617-646-8360
67110	Jason Balich	617-646-8498
67131	John Harmon Iii	617-646-8307
67336	Elisabeth Hunt	617-646-8443
68177	Oona Johnstone	617-504-4219
68598	Jennifer Wang	617-646-8392
69059	William Zhang	617-646-8257
70034	Cara Dawson	617-646-8000
70972	Daniel Rudoy	617-646-8303
71278	Daniel Smith	214-292-4071
72065	Mark Consilvio	202-408-3938
72100	David Gesner	617-646-8437
73256	Laura Rogers	212-336-3865
73865	Matthew Duffey	617-646-8537
73869	Zhiyun Ge	617-646-8472
73995	Curtis Powell	617-646-8534
74068	Jie Xiang	617-646-8000
74442	Lin Li	617-646-8502
74522	Kevin Macdonald	617-646-8497
75481	Philip Hamzik	617-646-8300
75857	Kirsten Weigel-Van Aken	202-350-2799
75967	Diana Borgas	(612) 339-3061
76050	Anant Saraswat	617-646-8187
76246	Adam Zeiger	617-646-8485
76538	Elizabeth Boehm	617-646-8000
76669	William Czaplyski	617-646-8494
76736	Michele Moresco	617-646-8000
76749	Danielle Samblanet	617-646-8565
76803	Amanda Varrichione	617-646-8161
76839	Jessica Von Reyn	617-646-8000
77021	Nathan Jacobs	617-646-8557
77065	Anne Weeks	617-646-8031
77265	Lingyin Ge	617-646-8199
77456	Saad Alam	617-646-8503
77641	Joseph Bowler	617-646-8393
77692	Elizabeth Mulski	617-646-8352
78514	Harrison Shecter	617-646-8183
78555	Andrew Varrenti	617-646-8314
78667	Flora Luo	617-646-8591
79027	Sarah Schlotter	617-646-8269
79358	Evan Jones	617-646-8000
79399	Andrew Maher	617-646-8596
79628	Tyler Goddard	617-646-8306
79725	Jeffrey Harrigan	617-646-8418
79773	Roshan Plamthottam	617-646-8770
79827	Charlotte Stewart-Sloan	617-646-8341
80263	Shangxing Lu	202-663-6000
80312	Samuel Doskocil	617-646-8198
80320	John Hovestadt	617-646-8348
80331	John Otterbein	908-420-6574
80350	Andrew Mathis	617-646-8562
80358	Colin Buss	617-646-8159
80498	Steven Hannigan	617-646-8573
80639	Edward Stanton	617-646-8873
80711	Kevin Chancellor	617-646-8373
80731	Samuel Kim	617-646-8000
81128	William Lindemann	617-646-8535
81205	Claire Lidston	617-646-8426
81429	Kylee Prosser	617-646-8590
81469	Victoria Julian	617-646-8495
81655	Jill Ryan	978-210-9065
81910	Conor Kavanagh	781-927-8679
81968	Joseph Noreika	212-849-3346
82138	Benjamin Walsh	617-646-8213
82211	Andrew Schlaus	212-849-3337
82354	Allison Mayne	617-646-8000
82491	Evan Bender	212-849-3351
82753	Adrienne Zagieboylo	617-646-8771
83072	Max Zegers	617-646-8660
83077	Samantha Collins	617-646-8564
83258	Karen Cruz	617-646-8444

Proceeding Documents

Notice: refund approved NOTICE

2025-01-27 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Dell Request for Refund (IPR2024-00481) OTHER

2025-01-21 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

DECISION Denying Petitioner’s Request for Rehearing of Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review 37 C.F.R. § 42.71 REHEARING

2024-09-11 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Petitioners' Request For Rehearing (IPR2024-00481) REHEARING

2024-06-27 FILING PARTY: PETITIONER

Download

Institution Decision: DECISION Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314 DECISION

2024-05-28 FILING PARTY: BOARD

Download

Dell Technologies Inc. et al. vs. LiTL LLC

Proceeding Overview

Parties & Counsel

Petitioner

Dell Technologies Inc. et al.

Represented By

Patent Owner / Respondent

LiTL LLC

Represented By

Tribunal & Venue

Patent Information

Address and Attorney/Agent Information

Power of Attorney & Correspondence

Attorney / Agent Information

Proceeding Documents

Notice: refund approved NOTICE

Dell Request for Refund (IPR2024-00481) OTHER

DECISION Denying Petitioner’s Request for Rehearing of Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review 37 C.F.R. § 42.71 REHEARING

Petitioners' Request For Rehearing (IPR2024-00481) REHEARING

Institution Decision: DECISION Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review 35 U.S.C. § 314 DECISION

Litl Webbook Beats ChromeOS, Becomes First Cloud Computer Exhibit

Scinto, Introducing The Litl WebBook. The Gadgeteer. (2009) Exhibit

Noe, The Litl Webbook: A more social computing device. (2009) Exhibit

All-New Litl Webbook Debuts at 2010 CES. Cision. (2010) Exhibit

U.S. Patent Pub. No. 2008/0251680A1 Exhibit

U.S. Patent No. 5,708,561 Exhibit

Saxena, CES 2010: All New Litl Webbook Makes Its Debut Appearance. Exhibit

Strauss, Litl Webbook Re-Defines Computing. ABC News. (2009) Exhibit

McDonald, LiTL Webbook Review. Little Tech Girl. (2010) Exhibit

U.S. Patent Pub. No. 2009/0179132A1 Exhibit

U.S. Patent Pub. No. 2007/0012827A1 Exhibit

U.S. Patent Pub. No. 2008/0035029A1 Exhibit

The Litl webbook. European Consumers Choice Exhibit

Declaration of Eric J. Gould in Support of Patent Owner Response to Non-Final Office Action Exhibit

Patent Owner's Preliminary Response POPR

Patent Owner's Mandatory Notices NOTICE

Notice: Notice filing date accorded NOTICE

POA - Asus Global Pte IPR2024-00481 (9563229) NOTICE

EX1016 - GB2321982A (Välikangas) Exhibit

EX1041 - 844 Patent Reexam Response to Office Action Exhibit

POA - Dell Technologies Inc. IPR2024-00481 (9563229) NOTICE

EX1042 - Complaint (LiTL v HP) Exhibit

EX1001 - US9563229 Exhibit

EX1011 - US6724403 (Santoro) Exhibit

EX1050 - Daniel C. Callaway Declaration Exhibit

EX1017 - CN2627170Y Exhibit

EX1043 - Complaint (LiTL v Dell) Exhibit

EX1028 - US20040066302 (Menard) Exhibit

EX1046 - Federal Court Management Statistics Exhibit

EX1033 - US6407914 (Helot) Exhibit

EX1039 - 844 Patent Reexam Notice of Intent to Issue Reexam Certificate Exhibit

EX1018 - CN2627170Y (Lin translation) Exhibit

EX1005 - WO9524007 (Lane) Exhibit

EX1020 - US6154359 (Kamikakai) Exhibit

EX1008 - US20050122318 (Tonouchi) Exhibit

EX1024 - US2880617 (Cotton) Exhibit

EX1030 - US20050155184 (Kayl) Exhibit

EX1029 - US6230564 (Matsunaga) Exhibit

EX1048 - CNET News.com (MIT) Exhibit

EX1003 - Expert Declaration of A. Wolfe (229 patent) Exhibit

EX1023 - US7688306 (Wehrenberg) Exhibit

EX1014 - InfoWorld - Epson HX-20 (1982) Exhibit

EX1031 - EP1640855A2 (Herberger) Exhibit

EX1036 - Precise Selection Techniques for Multi-Touch Screens Exhibit

Ranking of Petitions IPR2024-00481 (9563229) NOTICE

EX1009 - DE10331185A1 (Proll) Exhibit

EX1002 - File History for 229 Patent Exhibit

EX1012 - TechPowerUp Exhibit

EX1038 - 688 Patent Reexam Non-Final Office Action Exhibit

EX1010 - DE10331185 (Proll translation) Exhibit

POA - ASUSTeK Computer Inc. IPR2024-00481 (9563229) NOTICE

EX1049 - US20040212602 (Nako) Exhibit

EX1013 - TechTalk Exhibit

EX1032 - US5941965 (Moroz) Exhibit

EX1027 - WO2007010481 (Digon) Exhibit

EX1025 - US6851711 (Goertzen) Exhibit

POA - Dell Inc. IPR2024-00481 (9563229) NOTICE

POA - HP Inc. IPR2024-00481 (9563229) NOTICE

EX1019 - US20060034042 (Hisano) Exhibit

EX1045 - New York Times article Exhibit