Home › Unified Patent Court › UPC_CFI_204/2025

Smart Trike MNF. PTE Ltd vs. Brandline Group Społka Z Ograniczona Odpowiedzialnoscia

UPC_CFI_204/2025

Case Details

Case Number UPC_CFI_204/2025

Patent Number

EP2740655 EP3512765 EP2580109 EP1094878

Filing Date 2025-04-16

Proceeding Type Infringement

Case Phase Case Closed

Case Decision Date 16 April, 2025

Court Division Paris (FR) Central Division - Seat

Parties & Representative

Smart Trike MNF. PTE Ltd

Name Not Displayed For Gdpr Reasons. Represented By Gregoire Desrousseaux

1 Representative Listed

Representative

Brandline Group Społka Z Ograniczona Odpowiedzialnoscia

1 Representative Listed

Representative

Court / Division

Paris (FR) Central Division - Seat

Marjolein Visser

Maximilian Haedicke

Koen Callewaert

Patents Involved

There are 4 patents involved in this case.

Application Number	Patent Number	External Links
-	EP2740655	Espacenet Google Patents
-	EP3512765	Espacenet Google Patents
-	EP2580109	Espacenet Google Patents
-	EP1094878	Espacenet Google Patents

Docket Entries

Smart Trike MNF. PTE Ltd vs. Brandline Group Społka Z Ograniczona Odpowiedzialnoscia

Case Details

Parties & Representative

Claimants

Smart Trike MNF. PTE Ltd

Name Not Displayed For Gdpr Reasons. Represented By Gregoire Desrousseaux

Represented By

Defendants

Brandline Group Społka Z Ograniczona Odpowiedzialnoscia

Represented By

Court & Judges

Patents Involved

Docket Entries

CL3 Paris Local Division Order 17 January 2025 Raccords et Plastiques Nicoll SAS c First Plast France SA First Plast SRL

CL2 Paris Local Division Order 25 March 2024 IGB Srl c Unilever France UPCCFI4942023

CL2 Paris Local Division Order 25 March 2024 IGB Srl c Unilever France UPCCFI4942023

4878-00401-250416-R9 Application for non translation of some ex. of the SoC A signed

CL3 Paris Local Division Order 17 January 2025 Raccords et Plastiques Nicoll SAS c First Plast France SA First Plast SRL

CL1 Paris Local Division Order 12 January 2024 IGB Srl c Unilever France UPCCFI4942023

CL4 Paris Local Division Order 2 April 2025 Michelin c Goodyear UPCCFI1382025

CL1 Paris Local Division Order 12 January 2024 IGB Srl c Unilever France UPCCFI4942023

Acknowledgement-of-lodging

Exhibit 320 Bailiff report regarding the purchase of a Lionelo Tris Rose Grey Part 1

Exhibit 320 Bailiff report regarding the purchase of a Lionelo Tris Rose Grey Part 3

Exhibit 317 Extracts from the lionelo DE website

Exhibit 216 Response to the notice of opposition against EP109 from the patent proprietor

Exhibit 324 Invoice from Brandline to Smartrike DE

CL5 AIPPI Question Q213 The person skilled in the art in the context of the inventive step requirement in patent law

Exhibit 222 Online patent register of Germany France Italy and the Netherlands for EP655

CL4 Cass Com 20 November 2012 1118440

Exhibit 225 First communication from the Examining division dated 6 February 2015 for EP655

Exhibit 105 Extracts from the Polish National Court Register of Brandline

Exhibit 218 Withdrawal of the opposition against EP109

Exhibit 110 Extracts from the urbantrike website page Urban Mini Grey

Exhibit 108 Certified extracts from Register of the European Union Trade Mark Applications

Exhibit 321 Amazon invoice following order on the amazon FR website

Exhibit 320 Bailiff report regarding the purchase of a Lionelo Tris Rose Grey Part 2

Exhibit 313 Youtube video presenting the user manual of Lionelo Tris tricycle

Exhibit 212 Decision to grant EP109 and publication of the mention of the grant in the European Patent Bulletin

Exhibit 235 INPADOC patent family for EP765

Exhibit 214 Extract from a catalogue of tricycles cited as O1

Exhibit 324 Invoice from Brandline to Smartrike DE

Exhibit 302 Extracts from the Lionelo EN website

Exhibit 330 Video Lionelo Tris ticiclo published by Lionelo on YouTube

Exhibit 319 AFNIC domain name lionelofr

Exhibit 238 CN105501355

Exhibit 227 Second communication from the Examining division dated 11 February 2016 for EP655

Exhibit 213 Notice of opposition from Smoby against EP109

Exhibit 308 Extracts from the Lionelo Storefront on the amazon FR website

Exhibit 306 Extracts from the amazon IT website

Exhibit 219 Decision to discontinue the opposition proceedings against EP109

Exhibit 316 Extracts from the lionelo FR website

Exhibit 208 International search report and written opinion of WO2013 024371 EP109

Exhibit 214 Extract from a catalogue of tricycles cited as O1

Exhibit 210 Set of claims of EP109 filed at the entry into the European phase

Exhibit 326 Email confirming order of a Lionelo Tris tricycle on Amazon IT

Exhibit 221 Federated register of EP655

Exhibit 217 Summons to attend oral proceedings dated 6 October 2015 and preliminary opinion in the opposition proceedin

Exhibit 215 US2007 0096424

Exhibit 220 Patent EP 2 740 655

Exhibit 326 Email confirming order of a Lionelo Tris tricycle on Amazon IT

Exhibit 236 Patent application US2004 0256164

Exhibit 211 Communication under rule 71 3 EPC dated 5 June 2013 EP109

CL3 Central Division Paris Seat 26 December 2024 UPC3382023 UPC4102023

Exhibit 209 NL1023930 prior art EP109

Exhibit 111 Proof of wire transfer on the UPCs bank account

Exhibit 207 Patent application FR2930929

Exhibit 312 LIONELO TRIS tricycle photographs of the physical exhibit

Exhibit 229 Communication under Rule 71 3 EPC Exhibit 229 Communication under Rule 71 3 EPC dated 28 October 2016 for EP

Exhibit 105 Extracts from the Polish National Court Register of Brandline

Exhibit 206 Patent application FR2955080

Exhibit 307 Extracts from the amazon NL website

Exhibit 239 CN105480342

Exhibit 241 Communication under rule 71 3 EPC dated 9 March 2020 for EP765

Exhibit 239 CN105480342

Exhibit 238 CN105501355

Exhibit 329 Video Lionelo Tris dreirad published by Lionelo on YouTube

Exhibit 224 European search report and written opinion EP655

Exhibit 321 Amazon invoice following order on the amazon FR website

Exhibit 314 screenshots of the video presenting the user manual of Lionelo Tris tricycle